Cowherd Says Indiana Offense Stalls Without Mendoza
ESPN commentator Colin Cowherd argued Indiana's offense is far less effective without starting quarterback Fernando Mendoza.
Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Football

On the Wednesday episode of 'The Herd,' Colin Cowherd said Indiana's offense is a BB gun without Fernando Mendoza. Indiana fell five spots to No. 9 in the latest College Football Playoff rankings during its bye week.
Why it matters
The comments question how much of Indiana's 2025 national championship run depended on Mendoza, who now starts for the Las Vegas Raiders. The debate also focuses on the program's dependence on its quarterback as it prepares to host No. 18 USC.
Indiana's offense averaged 38 points per game against ranked opponents with Mendoza playing, compared with 15 points in three losses to ranked opponents without him. Cowherd's estimate that Cignetti deserves 90% of the title credit is an opinion and has not been tested against other measures.
The players
Colin Cowherd
Colin Cowherd is an American sports talk host known for his commentary on ESPN's programming, and he made these remarks on 'The Herd.'
Fernando Mendoza
Fernando Mendoza is a quarterback who led Indiana's 2025 national championship run and now starts for the Las Vegas Raiders.
Curt Cignetti
Curt Cignetti is the head football coach at Indiana, where he has compiled a 35-3 record since taking over the program.
The details
Cowherd said Indiana is a BB gun offensively without Mendoza, and he said Cignetti deserves about 90% of the credit for the title while Mendoza deserves about half. He also said he would not be shocked if USC beats Indiana on Saturday, and that Georgia, Notre Dame and Miami are the only three teams that can win the national championship this season.
Timeline
2025 season: Indiana won the national championship with Mendoza leading the offense.
Wednesday: Cowherd made the comments on 'The Herd.'
Saturday: Indiana is scheduled to host No. 18 USC.
The Tech Race
Indiana's 2025 national title under Curt Cignetti set the program's recent benchmark, and Cowherd's comments test whether that model survives the loss of its starting quarterback. The debate mirrors earlier questions about how much a single star can carry a title team in the Big Ten.
Fans tracking Indiana's College Football Playoff position should watch the Saturday matchup against USC, since a loss would further test the program's ranking. Those managing fantasy rosters with Indiana players may want to account for the team's scoring split with and without Mendoza.
The takeaway
The comments show how heavily Indiana's recent success has been tied to one quarterback, and the upcoming USC game will show whether the program can sustain its offense without him.
What happens next
Indiana hosts No. 18 USC on Saturday, which will test whether the offense can perform without Mendoza against a ranked opponent.
Further reading
For more on the Hoosiers' season, see Indiana Football.
Source note: This article includes information reported by FOX Sports.










