Heatherly Named Daily Southtown Volleyball Player of Year

Mother McAuley setter Peyton Heatherly earned the honor after leading the Mavericks to a Class 4A state championship.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Sports

Expressive editorial sports illustration in maroon and white, showing a volleyball setter reaching up to set the ball in a high school gym.
Mother McAuley setter Peyton Heatherly was named the 2026 Daily Southtown Girls Volleyball Player of the Year after leading the Mavericks to a Class 4A state title. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Mother McAuley senior setter Peyton Heatherly was named the 2026 Daily Southtown Girls Volleyball Player of the Year. The honor follows the Mavericks' Class 4A state title, a 38-4 season in which Heatherly finished her career with 2,919 assists.

Why it matters

The award recognizes one of the most productive setters in the area this season, and her career assist total ranks 13th in Illinois High School Association record book history. It also highlights a Chicago-area program that closed its season with a state championship.

Heatherly recorded 708 assists, 220 digs, 38 kills, 31 aces and 16 blocks this season, and her 2,919 career assists rank 13th in Illinois High School Association record book history. The extraction does not indicate how the selection panel weighed these figures against other candidates.

The players

Peyton Heatherly

Heatherly is a senior setter for Mother McAuley and a Coastal Carolina recruit who comes from a multigenerational volleyball family.

Mother McAuley

Mother McAuley is a Chicago-area Catholic high school whose volleyball program won the Class 4A state championship this season.

The details

Heatherly, a Coastal Carolina recruit, is the third generation of her family to play volleyball. In the state semifinal against Oak Park-River Forest, McAuley dropped the first game 25-16 before winning the next two 25-17 and 25-18, with Heatherly delivering a huddle speech between games. She finished the state final win over Libertyville with 37 assists and four aces.

Timeline

  1. 2023: Heatherly played for the Mother McAuley team that won the state championship.

  2. Nov. 13, 2026: McAuley lost game one of the state semifinal to Oak Park-River Forest.

Season Trajectory

Heatherly's selection continues a run of recent state success for Mother McAuley, which first won the Class 4A title in 2023 with her on the roster. Her 2,919-assist career places her among the most prolific setters in Illinois High School Association history.

Heatherly's career assist total places her among the most productive setters in Illinois high school history, a benchmark that fantasy and recruiting observers can track as college programs evaluate her next step. The state title also confirms Mother McAuley as a defending-level program for the next season's Class 4A competition.

The takeaway

Heatherly's award reflects a career built across multiple state-title seasons, showing how sustained participation in a single program can produce lasting statistical records. Readers following Chicago-area high school sports can use the season and career totals to compare players across seasons.

Further reading

Explore more Chicago volleyball coverage for the season's top programs and players.