ESPN's Cohen Picks Caleb Williams for Playoff Trust
ESPN analyst Evan Cohen named Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams the NFC North signal-caller he would trust most in a playoff game.
Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Football

On ESPN's First Take, analyst Evan Cohen chose Caleb Williams over Jared Goff, Jordan Love and Kirk Cousins as the NFC North quarterback he would trust most in a playoff game. The endorsement drew criticism from NFL fans citing Williams' recent interception totals.
Why it matters
The pick puts Williams' playoff reliability under scrutiny after interception-heavy outings in Chicago's recent games. Cohen said Williams' coach and their connection with that coach drove the choice, and cited Williams' 'IT factor.'
Williams threw four interceptions in Chicago's 27-24 Week 9 win over Tampa Bay and two in the January wild-card win over Green Bay. Through Week 9 he has thrown five interceptions, eight touchdowns and carries a PFN QB Impact Grade of 81.9, though the sample remains the regular season.
The players
Evan Cohen
Evan Cohen is an ESPN analyst who appears on the network's First Take program, where he offers commentary on NFL quarterbacks and teams.
Caleb Williams
Caleb Williams is the Chicago Bears quarterback who was selected first overall in the 2024 NFL Draft out of USC.
The details
Cohen made the pick in response to a question on ESPN's First Take, stating he believed in Williams and in Williams' connection with his coach. Critics pointed to Williams' three-interception overtime loss to the Rams and the Bears' 31-27 wild-card win over Green Bay as evidence of the risk.
Timeline
January 2026: Williams threw two interceptions in the Bears' 31-27 wild-card win over Green Bay.
Week 9: Williams threw four interceptions in the Bears' 27-24 win over Tampa Bay.
Nov. 22: The Bears host the New Orleans Saints at Soldier Field.
Christmas Day: The Packers visit Soldier Field.
Season Trajectory
The pick bears on the NFC North race and the Bears' playoff standing, since Williams' reliability in a single-elimination game would shape Chicago's chances against divisional rivals. It also reflects how public evaluation of young quarterbacks often rests on a few high-profile results.
Fantasy managers weighing Williams for playoff lineups have a concrete reliability question, given five interceptions through Week 9. Bears fans can track whether Williams' interception total changes before the Saints game at Soldier Field on Nov. 22.
The takeaway
Quarterback reliability in the playoffs is judged on a small number of games, so a single endorsement reflects an opinion rather than settled evidence. Readers can weigh the interception totals and season statistics directly when forming their own view.
Further reading
Explore more Football coverage for Chicago readers.






