Chicago Candidates Propose Restoring School Ratings
Ten school board candidates are pushing to bring back a singular performance rating system for local public schools.
Updated on Oct. 28, 2026 in Secondary Education
Live Poll
Should your local school district use simple letter or number grades to rate school performance?
Ten of 44 school board candidates in Chicago are advocating for the return of a singular school rating system, which was phased out three years ago. Supporters argue these ratings provide essential feedback, while critics contend they unfairly label schools serving low-income Black and Latino students.
Why it matters
The debate highlights a significant rift regarding school accountability, as current district policies favor a dashboard approach that monitors 20 different performance measures rather than a single grade. The outcome of the election could determine whether Chicago Public Schools shifts back toward simplified oversight or continues with its current multi-factor evaluation model.
Chicago Public Schools currently utilizes a 20-measure dashboard to track performance rather than a singular rating. While 10 candidates support returning to a traditional rating scale, nine support the expansion of charter schools.
The players
Victor Henderson
He is a school board candidate who has publicly expressed support for the return of a singular school rating system.
Illinois Network of Charter Schools
This organization operates a political arm that has invested millions into the current school board election to influence the composition of the board.
Chicago Public Schools
It is the primary public school district in Chicago currently managing school performance oversight through a 20-measure dashboard.
The details
The previous rating system categorized schools on a scale ranging from Level 1+ to Level 3 before being replaced. The Illinois Network of Charter Schools has engaged in the election, spending over $2.3 million to support 19 candidates and over $600,000 to oppose two others, reflecting broader disagreements over the city's school choice system.
Timeline
Chicago Public Schools discontinued the use of singular school performance ratings three years ago.
The most recent new charter school in the district opened in 2019.
Culture Shift
The push to reinstate ratings marks a departure from Chicago Public Schools' school choice system and its current reliance on a 20-measure dashboard. This debate pits traditional performance benchmarking against the modern trend of using complex, multifaceted data to evaluate educational institutions.
Parents and local residents may see significant changes in how school quality is communicated if a board favoring singular ratings is elected. This shift could impact how families navigate the current school choice system and influence future decisions regarding charter school enrollment.
The takeaway
The upcoming school board election is a critical junction for families evaluating the future of local educational accountability. Residents should monitor candidate stances on rating systems to understand how potential policy changes may impact their school choice options.
Further reading
For more information on the district's evaluation standards, visit the Secondary Education section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Chicago Sun-Times.
Live Poll
Should your local school district use simple letter or number grades to rate school performance?
