Chicago Officer Retained After Killing Dog
An officer involved in the fatal shooting of a dog in April 2024 remains on the force despite firing recommendations.
Updated on Sept. 25, 2026 in Dogs
Live Poll
Do you trust your local police department to hold officers accountable for confirmed misconduct?
In April 2024, Chicago police officer Carmen Mostek shot and killed a dog named Aggie while the pet was being held by its owner, Kent Maynard. Despite recommendations for termination, the officer remains employed by the Chicago Police Department.
Why it matters
The incident highlights ongoing scrutiny regarding police use of force and the accountability processes within the department when internal recommendations are not enacted. The case remains a point of contention as it pits official disciplinary findings against the current employment status of the officer.
COPA investigators recommended that Carmen Mostek be fired for improper use of force and false statements regarding the shooting. The police board currently maintains that no disciplinary case exists as formal charges were never filed.
The players
Carmen Mostek
She is a Chicago police officer currently assigned to the Alternate Response Section.
Kent Maynard
He is the owner of the dog that was killed during the police encounter.
Larry Snelling
He is the former Superintendent of the Chicago Police Department who supported the termination recommendation.
The details
Surveillance footage captured the moment Carmen Mostek fired her weapon at the dog, which was being held by Kent Maynard at the time. Mostek claimed she acted to protect her own corgi during the encounter.
Timeline
The shooting occurred in April 2024.
Superintendent Larry Snelling supported the recommendation to terminate the officer in January 2026.
Culture Shift
This incident follows the complex patterns of accountability established by the Chicago Police Department's internal disciplinary review process. It highlights a departure from standard procedural expectations when internal findings are met with administrative inaction.
Residents in Chicago may find this incident relevant to ongoing public discussions regarding police conduct and neighborhood safety. The pending civil case may ultimately influence future policies regarding how officers interact with pets in public spaces.
The takeaway
This case underscores the importance of transparency in police disciplinary procedures for pet owners and the general public. Residents are encouraged to remain informed about the status of local civil cases that may affect neighborhood safety standards.
Further reading
Learn more about local regulations and advocacy regarding Dogs in the Chicago area.
Source note: This article includes information reported by CBS News.
Live Poll
Do you trust your local police department to hold officers accountable for confirmed misconduct?
