Supreme Court Names Colosimo Circuit Judge

Yorkville alderman and former associate judge Carlo Colosimo was unanimously selected to fill a 23rd Circuit vacancy.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in People

Supreme Court Names Colosimo Circuit Judge

Live Poll

Do you trust local judges appointed rather than elected to serve your community fairly?

The Illinois Supreme Court unanimously appointed Carlo Colosimo as resident circuit judge of the 23rd Judicial Circuit, which covers Kendall and DeKalb counties. The appointment fills the vacancy left by retiring Judge Robert Pilmer.

Why it matters

The appointment places a judge with prior prosecutorial, city council and associate-judge experience on the circuit bench for Illinois residents in Kendall and DeKalb counties. Colosimo will have to run for election when his term expires in two years.

The appointment carries a two-year term before Colosimo must stand for election, following Judge Robert Pilmer's November 30 retirement. Colosimo previously served four years as an associate judge in Kendall County and eight years on the Yorkville City Council from 2011 to 2019.

The players

Carlo Colosimo

Carlo Colosimo is a former Yorkville alderman and Kendall County prosecutor who was appointed to the 23rd Judicial Circuit bench.

Robert Pilmer

Robert Pilmer is a retiring judge of the 23rd Judicial Circuit whose department created the vacancy filled by Colosimo.

The details

Justice Elizabeth Rochford, the justice for the Second Judicial District, recommended Colosimo, and the Illinois Supreme Court selected him unanimously. Colosimo previously worked as a prosecutor in the Kendall County State's Attorney's office and rose to captain in the U.S. Army Judge Advocate General division.

Timeline

  1. April 2011: Colosimo began serving on the Yorkville City Council.

  2. April 2019: Colosimo's Yorkville City Council service ended.

  3. 2022: Colosimo was appointed associate judge.

  4. November 30, 2026: Judge Robert Pilmer retired.

  5. December 1, 2026: Colosimo's term as circuit judge begins.

Legacy Context

Under Illinois' judicial selection system, the Illinois Supreme Court fills circuit vacancies by appointment, and appointees must stand for election when their terms expire, as Colosimo will in two years.

Residents of Kendall and DeKalb counties will have a new circuit judge presiding over their cases beginning December 1. Voters will have a chance to weigh in on Colosimo when his term expires in two years.

The takeaway

Judicial appointments can shape local courts for years, so voters in the 23rd Circuit have a continuing stake in who holds these seats. Following the upcoming election is the clearest way to track the outcome.

What happens next

Colosimo's circuit judge term begins December 1, 2026, following Judge Robert Pilmer's retirement on November 30.

Further reading

Explore more people profiles in business news.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Shaw Local.

Live Poll

Do you trust local judges appointed rather than elected to serve your community fairly?