Judge Sentences Smith to 10 Years for DUI
A 73-year-old man convicted of his third felony DUI received a 10-year prison term with parole eligibility after one year.
Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Live Poll
Should repeat drunk drivers face longer prison sentences than they currently do?
Judge Barry McHugh sentenced Michael Scott Smith, 73, to 10 years in prison on Wednesday after he was convicted of his third felony DUI. McHugh also suspended Smith's driving privileges for five years following his release from prison.
Why it matters
The sentence reflects the escalating consequences for repeat felony DUI offenders, as Smith has five lifetime DUIs and prior felony convictions in 2008 and 2018. The case underscores how prior probation compliance does not prevent future offenses.
Smith is in custody and was sentenced Wednesday to 10 years in prison with parole eligibility after one year. He faces a five-year driver's license suspension beginning upon release, and it is not yet known whether he will appeal.
The players
Michael Scott Smith
Michael Scott Smith is a 73-year-old Coeur d'Alene man with five lifetime DUIs who was convicted of his third felony DUI.
Judge Barry McHugh
Judge Barry McHugh is the Kootenai County judge who presided over the sentencing and imposed the prison term and driving suspension.
The details
Smith was pulled over at 1 p.m. on Feb. 12 during a routine traffic stop, where he displayed signs of intoxication and failed field sobriety evaluations. He provided two breath samples measuring .177 and .171, and he was arrested and held through sentencing.
Timeline
2008: Smith's first prior felony DUI conviction.
2018: Smith's second prior felony DUI conviction.
Feb. 12: Smith pulled over during a routine traffic stop at 1 p.m.
Wednesday: Judge McHugh sentenced Smith to prison.
One year after sentencing: Smith becomes eligible for parole.
Legal Context
Idaho's felony DUI statute escalates penalties for repeat impaired-driving offenses after multiple prior convictions, and Smith's sentence applies that framework to his third felony. The case illustrates how repeat offenders face prison terms and extended license suspensions under the state's escalating penalty structure.
Repeat DUI offenders face prison time and long license suspensions, which removes dangerous drivers from Coeur d'Alene roads for extended periods. Residents can expect the suspension to keep Smith off the road for years after any release.
The takeaway
Repeat felony DUI convictions carry escalating consequences, and the sentence reflects how probation completion in earlier cases does not guarantee future compliance. Drivers facing impaired-driving charges should understand that each conviction increases the penalty they face.
What happens next
Smith becomes eligible for parole one year after sentencing, and his five-year driver's license suspension begins upon his release from prison.
Further reading
For more on how repeat impaired-driving cases move through the system, see Criminal Justice coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Coeur d'Alene Press.
Live Poll
Should repeat drunk drivers face longer prison sentences than they currently do?










