Jurgensen Wins Caldwell Mayoral Race

Essex County Clerk's Office released official 2026 general election results showing Kenneth Jurgensen defeating incumbent Garrett Jones.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in City Hall

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain municipal civic building with a flagpole, rendered in deep red, cream, and navy.
Kenneth Jurgensen defeated incumbent Republican Mayor Garrett Jones 52% to 48% in Caldwell's mayoral race, official Essex County results show. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust your local government to serve Caldwell well?

Kenneth Jurgensen won the Caldwell mayoral race over Republican incumbent Garrett Jones, receiving 1,652 votes (52.11%) to Jones's 1,518 (47.89%). Democratic candidates Jonathan Sagalow and Mark Heftler also won two Caldwell borough council seats.

Why it matters

The result changes the leadership of Caldwell's municipal government, with Jurgensen replacing a sitting mayor. Republicans will still hold a 4-2 majority on the borough council, shaping how the two sides must work together on local decisions.

Jurgensen won by 134 votes, or 4.22 percentage points, over Jones, with the council seats going to the top two Democratic candidates in a field of four. The source does not specify the swearing-in date or whether any results are subject to recount or challenge.

The players

Kenneth Jurgensen

Kenneth Jurgensen is the newly elected mayor of Caldwell, New Jersey, who defeated the incumbent in the 2026 general election.

Garrett Jones

Garrett Jones is the Republican incumbent mayor of Caldwell, New Jersey, who sought re-election and lost to Kenneth Jurgensen.

Essex County Clerk's Office

The Essex County Clerk's Office is the county government office in New Jersey that administers elections and certifies official vote results.

The details

Jones launched his re-election campaign in spring 2026 alongside council candidates Pollara and Bambrick. After Alcorta withdrew from the council race for family reasons, Heftler was added to the ticket and won a seat with Sagalow.

Timeline

  1. Spring 2026: Jones launches re-election campaign with Pollara and Bambrick.

  2. Wednesday, November 18, 2026: Essex County Clerk's Office releases official results.

Political Context

Caldwell's council remains under Republican control with a 4-2 majority even as the mayoralty changes hands, meaning Jurgensen will govern alongside a council his party does not control. The split mirrors a local pattern where mayoral and council races in Essex County can produce divided municipal leadership.

The election determines who runs Caldwell's municipal administration and sets the borough's direction on local spending and services. Residents will see the change in leadership but the council's Republican majority means policy continuity on many local matters is likely.

The takeaway

Local election outcomes often hinge on narrow margins, and a 134-vote gap changed Caldwell's mayoralty. Readers who want to track how the new administration and divided council work together should follow future City Hall meetings.

Further reading

For more on the local government behind these results, see City Hall coverage of Caldwell's municipal leadership.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Patch.

Live Poll

Do you trust your local government to serve Caldwell well?