Fresco Market Wins Progress Best Slice in Town
The Caldwell establishment earned the top honor following a community-wide online poll.
Updated on Oct. 27, 2026 in Italian Food
Live Poll
Do you prefer relying on public polls to determine the best local restaurants in your community?
Fresco Market and Catering at 115 Bloomfield Ave in Caldwell secured the title of Best Slice in Town after winning an inaugural contest. The local shop beat out roughly 10 other participating pizza establishments.
Why it matters
The competition highlighted local pizza quality and preferences across the region, culminating in an official recognition for the winning business.
The contest featured approximately 10 local establishments competing for the top honor. To refine their dough, Fresco utilizes all-natural, unbleached, and unbromated flour.
The players
Fresco Market and Catering
This establishment is a local business located at 115 Bloomfield Ave in Caldwell.
Chris and John Mungo
They are the owners of Fresco Market and Catering who accepted the award on behalf of the business.
The details
Residents cast their votes through an online poll that ran throughout the early fall. The winning shop, which has served the area since 2015, received a commemorative pizza pan for their achievement.
Timeline
Fresco Market and Catering began operations in 2015.
Voting for the contest began at the start of September 2026.
The voting period officially concluded on October 14, 2026.
Fresco was announced as the contest winner on October 23, 2026.
Owners Chris and John Mungo received their commemorative pan on October 26, 2026.
Culture Shift
This victory reflects a broader trend of digital community engagement being used to identify and elevate local favorites. It signifies a move toward hyper-local food appreciation that replaces traditional word-of-mouth with measurable, public data.
Residents may see increased foot traffic at the 115 Bloomfield Ave location following the shop's public recognition as the contest winner. Customers can expect the shop to continue using their signature all-natural, unbromated dough formulation.
The takeaway
Supporting long-standing local businesses can be a great way to engage with the specific culinary strengths of your neighborhood. Consider visiting local establishments that utilize high-quality ingredients like unbromated flour to experience the difference in their offerings.
Further reading
Discover more about local dining favorites in our guide to Italian Food.
Source note: This article includes information reported by New Jersey Hills.
Live Poll
Do you prefer relying on public polls to determine the best local restaurants in your community?
