Boise Police Arrest Owner of Ethical Remodeling
Toby Tibbitts faces felony charges following an investigation into uncompleted home siding projects.
Updated on Oct. 28, 2026 in Property Crime
Live Poll
Do you trust local remodeling contractors in your area to finish projects they are paid for?
Boise police have arrested the owner of Ethical Remodeling, Toby Tibbitts, on two counts of felony grand theft. Authorities allege Tibbitts accepted thousands of dollars for home siding work that was never performed.
Why it matters
The investigation highlights risks to homeowners when contractors accept significant advance payments but fail to deliver contracted services. Detectives are currently seeking information from other potential victims who may have entered similar agreements.
Toby Tibbitts faces two counts of felony grand theft and was booked into the Ada County Jail. His current bail status and upcoming court appearances remain under investigation.
The players
Toby Tibbitts
He is the owner of Ethical Remodeling who now faces felony charges.
Boise Police Department
This local agency conducted the investigation into the reported grand theft cases.
Ada County Jail
This is the correctional facility where the suspect was processed following his arrest.
The details
Boise police conducted a thorough investigation into the theft reports after victims signed siding contracts on two separate dates. Despite receiving thousands of dollars, Tibbitts and Ethical Remodeling reportedly abandoned the projects.
Timeline
May 7, 2026: Victims signed a contract for a home siding job.
July 11, 2026: Victims signed a second contract for a siding project.
October 15, 2026: Toby Tibbitts was arrested and booked into the Ada County Jail.
Legal Context
This case follows the state legal frameworks defined by Idaho's felony grand theft statutes regarding theft of services and currency. Such prosecutions often serve to deter contractors from violating consumer protection laws in the local area.
Residents who have contracted with Ethical Remodeling are encouraged to contact investigators if they experienced similar unfulfilled project agreements. The department suggests documenting all financial exchanges and signed contracts to assist in the ongoing inquiry.
The takeaway
Homeowners should always verify contractor licenses and avoid paying large portions of project costs upfront. Maintaining detailed records of every financial transaction is essential for protecting yourself against potential fraud.
Further reading
For more information on similar local cases, visit the Property Crime section.
Live Poll
Do you trust local remodeling contractors in your area to finish projects they are paid for?
