JCPenney Counters Developer Over Valley West Mall
The retailer alleges the owner breached its 50-year lease by failing to maintain the property and planning to demolish it.
Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Commercial

Live Poll
Do you think big retailers and developers stalling old malls hurts your community?
JCPenney filed a counterclaim in Polk County District Court on Nov. 3 in response to a lawsuit from Project 1551 LLC, which bought Valley West Mall for $11 million on Sept. 28. The retailer alleges the owner failed to operate and maintain the 865,000-square-foot mall, terminated tenant leases and announced plans to demolish it without approval.
Why it matters
The dispute centers on whether a redevelopment of the aging West Des Moines mall can proceed while JCPenney's lease runs through 2032. The outcome could shape how the site is repurposed in a market where the mall's assessed value has fallen 80% since 2005.
The mall's 865,000 square feet were assessed at $19.8 million, an 80% decline from 2005 levels, and Watson Centers Inc. owed nearly $3.5 million to U.S. Bank before the property went to foreclosure. JCPenney's 50-year lease runs to 2032, and the court has not yet ruled on the retailer's claims for lost profits and replacement costs.
The players
JCPenney
A Plano, Texas-based department store chain with a long history as an anchor tenant in American malls.
Polk County District Court
The Iowa trial court in which the counterclaim was filed and where the dispute will be heard.
The details
JCPenney alleges Project 1551 LLC breached the lease by failing to operate and maintain the property, terminating leases of remaining tenants and announcing demolition plans without its approval. The retailer says the actions are causing damages including past and future lost profits and higher utility, security, entrance and signage costs. The mall was placed on the market in February 2025, three years after entering foreclosure.
Timeline
Valley West Mall opened in 1975.
Peak assessed value and activity came in 2005.
The mall was listed for sale in February 2025.
Project 1551 LLC bought the mall on Sept. 28, 2025.
JCPenney filed its counterclaim on Nov. 3, 2025.
Commercial Shift
The dispute follows the pattern set when Jordan Creek Town Center opened in the early 2000s and pulled shoppers from older West Des Moines malls. Valley West's 80% assessed-value drop since 2005 places the redevelopment fight within that continuing decline in the local retail market.
Residents of West Des Moines may see changes to a major shopping site depending on how the lease dispute is resolved. Any demolition or redevelopment would affect nearby shoppers and tenants who currently rely on the mall.
The takeaway
Long-term leases can constrain how aging commercial property is redeveloped, so ownership changes often trigger legal disputes. Watching how the Polk County case resolves will show how similar retail sites in the region may be repurposed.
Further reading
Explore more commercial real estate coverage on how retail properties are being repurposed across the metro.
Live Poll
Do you think big retailers and developers stalling old malls hurts your community?






