Trout Case Returns to Seneca Grand Jury

Former Waterloo supervisor Don Trout's criminal case will be presented to a new grand jury this month.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Crime — General

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a modest municipal brick building centered against a solid field, evoking a quiet local civic setting.
Former Waterloo Town Supervisor Don Trout's criminal case will return to a new Seneca County grand jury this month, under an agreement reached by prosecutors and the defense. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Former Waterloo Town Supervisor Don Trout's criminal case will go before a new Seneca County grand jury this month, under an agreement reached by special prosecutor Todd Casella, defense attorney Ralph Alloco and County Judge Barry Porsch. Trout pleaded not guilty to charges that prosecutors allege stem from a March 2024 entry into Waterloo's Highway Department building.

Why it matters

The new presentation follows a challenge by Trout's attorney that Trout was denied an opportunity to testify before the first grand jury. The re-presentation does not determine Trout's guilt or innocence, and the case will proceed through the court process from there for the Waterloo community and Seneca County residents.

Trout remains free on his own recognizance and has pleaded not guilty to the charges, which prosecutors allege arise from the March 2024 incident at the Waterloo Highway Department building. The new grand jury presentation is scheduled for this month, and no trial date has been reported.

The players

Don Trout

Former Waterloo Town Supervisor who pleaded not guilty to charges his attorney is contesting in court.

Bob Lotz

Former Waterloo Town Board member who pleaded guilty to fourth-degree criminal mischief and agreed to testify at any trial of Trout.

Todd Casella

Special prosecutor handling the criminal case against Don Trout in Seneca County.

Ralph Alloco

Defense attorney representing Don Trout, who sought dismissal of the case and agreed to the new grand jury presentation.

Barry Porsch

Seneca County Judge who agreed to the new grand jury presentation in the Trout case.

The details

Prosecutors accuse Trout and former Town Board member Bob Lotz of damaging a television that some board members had directed be removed. Lotz pleaded guilty to fourth-degree criminal mischief, a misdemeanor, in April. Trout's attorney had sought dismissal of the case in June, arguing that Trout was not given an opportunity to exercise his right to testify before the first grand jury.

Timeline

  1. March 2024: Alleged entry into the Waterloo Highway Department building.

  2. April: Lotz pleaded guilty to fourth-degree criminal mischief.

  3. June: Trout's attorney sought dismissal of the case.

  4. November 2026: Case is scheduled to go before a new Seneca County grand jury.

Legal Context

The challenge centers on a defendant's right to testify before a grand jury, a procedural protection that courts enforce when a defendant was not given the chance to appear. Re-presenting a case to a new grand jury is a common remedy when such a defect is found, and it allows the process to proceed without deciding guilt or innocence.

Residents of Waterloo and Seneca County can follow the case through the county court system, as the grand jury decision will determine whether the charges against Trout move forward to trial. The outcome may also affect how Lotz's testimony obligation is applied if a trial occurs.

The takeaway

A grand jury re-presentation does not establish guilt, so the case should be followed through its formal steps rather than assumed resolved. Readers interested in local court outcomes can track the Seneca County grand jury's decision when it is announced this month.

What happens next

Trout's case is scheduled to return to a Seneca County grand jury this month, which will decide whether to issue an indictment.

Further reading

Explore more Crime — General coverage for additional context on local criminal proceedings in Waterloo.