Hilo Police Arrested Suspect in September Burglary
Authorities apprehended 47-year-old Sheldon Pagan in connection with a property crime on Kalanianaole Street.
Updated on Oct. 4, 2026 in Property Crime
Live Poll
In your community, do you support police using public tips to help identify criminal suspects?
Hawai'i Island police arrested Sheldon Pagan on November 5, 2024, following a September 15 burglary at a Hilo business. Public tips helped authorities identify the 47-year-old suspect from surveillance footage.
Why it matters
Law enforcement rely on community surveillance assistance to identify suspects in property crimes where perpetrators remain at large. The arrest marks a significant procedural step as police continue to investigate the involvement of a second, unidentified male suspect.
Sheldon Pagan is currently held on a $43,000 bail after being charged with second-degree burglary, second-degree theft, and third-degree criminal property damage.
The players
Sheldon Pagan
A 47-year-old man who was arrested and charged with multiple offenses including burglary and theft.
Hawai'i Island Police
The local law enforcement agency responsible for investigating the burglary and apprehending the suspect.
The details
Video surveillance captured two male suspects during the incident on Kalanianaole Street, leading to public tips that confirmed Pagan's identity. Authorities have officially filed charges against Pagan, while the investigation into the second participant continues.
Timeline
September 15, 2024: The burglary occurred at a business on Kalanianaole Street in Hilo.
November 5, 2024: Police arrested and charged Sheldon Pagan following public identification.
Legal Context
This case reflects the growing reliance on public-sourced visual evidence to expedite arrests in local property crime investigations. The arrest follows the investigative success patterns established by the Hawaii County Police Department community-policing initiative.
Residents in the Kalanianaole Street area are encouraged to review home security footage and report any information regarding the unidentified second suspect to police. Increased surveillance and neighborhood watch participation remain recommended strategies for local business owners.
The takeaway
Securing local business premises with reliable video surveillance continues to be a primary deterrent and tool for law enforcement. Residents should remain vigilant and report suspicious activity to help expedite the resolution of active criminal investigations.
Further reading
For more information on local safety trends, visit the Property Crime section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Hawaiipolice.
Live Poll
In your community, do you support police using public tips to help identify criminal suspects?
