Maui Vessel Owners Settle Coral Damage Case

State board approves a $375,000 settlement tied to a 2023 vessel grounding near Honolua Bay.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Environmental

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a dark volcanic headland over turquoise reef water with pale fractured coral, rendered in navy, cream, and oxblood.
Maui vessel owners agreed to pay a $375,000 state settlement over coral and live rock damage from a February 2023 grounding near Honolua Bay. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think penalties for damaging local ocean environments are strong enough?

The Hawaii Board of Land and Natural Resources approved a $375,000 settlement with a Maui vessel owner and spouse over stony coral and live rock damage from a February 2023 vessel grounding near Honolua Bay. Separately, the owners paid a fine of several hundred thousand dollars in September 2026 to settle a federal Oil Pollution Act case.

Why it matters

The settlement reflects the severity of the violation and the burden the grounding placed on the West Maui community, including blocked ocean and shoreline access from Honolua Bay to Lipoa Point for multiple weeks. It shows how state and federal authorities are pursuing accountability for damage to marine resources.

The settlement covers 119 stony coral colonies and 1,640.5 square meters of live rock damaged in the grounding, compared with a board fine assessment of $1,818,851.97 issued in April 2024. The owners will pay almost $1,000,000 in combined settlements for natural resource damage, and the charter company's accountability remains unresolved.

The players

Hawaii Board of Land and Natural Resources

The state board that oversees Hawaii's public lands and natural resources and approved the settlement.

U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Hawaiʻi

The federal prosecutor's office that filed charges under the Oil Pollution Act of 1990 in September 2025.

The details

DLNR's Division of Aquatic Resources reached proposed settlement terms with a Maui vessel owner and spouse at a September 26, 2025 hearing after a dispute over a contested case hearing that a First Circuit Court remand ordered the board to conduct. DAR held a West Maui community public meeting on February 22, 2024 to gather input before the settlement was reached.

Timeline

  1. February 2023: Vessel grounding occurs near Honolua Bay.

  2. July 28, 2023: DLNR DAR initiates enforcement against the vessel operator and owners.

  3. February 22, 2024: DAR holds a West Maui community public meeting.

  4. April 26, 2024: Board increases fine assessment to $1,818,851.97.

  5. September 26, 2025: DAR and the owners reach proposed $375,000 settlement terms.

Big Picture

The settlement sits alongside federal enforcement under the Oil Pollution Act of 1990, showing state and federal authorities pursuing parallel penalties for the same grounding. Together, the two actions illustrate how vessel damage to Hawaii's coral reefs can draw both state settlements and federal charges.

Residents and visitors who use Honolua Bay and the nearby shoreline should expect continued enforcement attention on vessel groundings that damage reef habitat. Charter operators in West Maui face direct consequences for groundings, including state settlements and possible federal charges.

The takeaway

Vessel groundings on reefs can lead to multi-agency enforcement and substantial payments for damage to marine resources. Boaters and charter operators should confirm their vessel's route and anchoring plans before operating near sensitive coral areas.

What happens next

Accountability against the vessel's operator and charter company will be addressed at a future hearing.

Further reading

Explore more on Environmental coverage of marine damage and enforcement across Hawaii.

Live Poll

Do you think penalties for damaging local ocean environments are strong enough?