Kamehameha Schools Seeks Dismissal of Lawsuit

The school asks a federal judge to toss a challenge to its Native Hawaiian admissions preference, and no ruling has been issued.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Education

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a single civic building across a palm-lined lawn under a volcanic ridgeline, in oxblood and cream, suggesting a pending legal question.
A federal judge in Honolulu has not yet ruled on Kamehameha Schools' motion to dismiss a lawsuit challenging its Native Hawaiian admissions preference. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should private schools be allowed to prefer applicants based on ancestry?

Kamehameha Schools has filed a motion asking a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit challenging its preference for Native Hawaiian applicants. A hearing on the motion was held in federal court in Honolulu, and the judge issued no ruling.

Why it matters

The case tests whether an admissions preference tied to Native Hawaiian identity can withstand a legal challenge brought on the grounds of racial discrimination. A decision on whether the case proceeds will shape how Hawaii's private schools handle ancestry-based admissions and the agreements families enter with them.

The school has dropped tuition, which it argues removed the contracts at the center of the challenge, while Students for Fair Admissions contends families still enter agreements with the school through its rules and policies. The judge has not said whether the case will move forward.

The players

Kamehameha Schools

A private school system in Hawaii founded with an endowment from the estate of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, which gives preference to Native Hawaiian students in admissions.

Students for Fair Admissions

A national nonprofit that has brought legal challenges against race-conscious admissions policies at colleges and schools.

The details

Students for Fair Admissions brought the lawsuit on behalf of unnamed plaintiffs, arguing the preference amounts to racial discrimination. Kamehameha Schools argues the plaintiffs had not shown grounds to sue when the case began and that previous Congressional actions protect its admissions preference. A vigil was held at Kawaiahao Place before the hearing.

Timeline

  1. November 18, 2026: Hearing on the motion to dismiss held in federal court in Honolulu; no ruling issued.

Culture Shift

The case sits within a broader legal challenge to race- and ancestry-conscious admissions, a debate that has moved from universities into private secondary schools. Whether Congressional protections for Native Hawaiian programs survive this challenge will signal how far such preferences can reach beyond higher education.

Families weighing applications to Kamehameha Schools should note that tuition has been dropped while the school's admissions preference remains under legal review. The outcome of the motion to dismiss will determine whether current eligibility rules continue unchanged for applicants.

The takeaway

Admissions rules at private schools can be challenged even after a school changes how it charges families, so applicants should read current eligibility criteria carefully before applying. The judge's ruling on the motion to dismiss will clarify whether the preference stands for the upcoming application cycle.

Further reading

For more on how admissions rules shape application decisions, see College Applications.

Live Poll

Should private schools be allowed to prefer applicants based on ancestry?