Sarasota Players Launched Auditorium Fundraising Campaign

The nonprofit theater seeks $500,000 to renovate the Payne Park Auditorium after consecutive years of financial losses.

Updated on Sept. 27, 2026 in Arts Theater — General

Bold vector editorial illustration of a lone stage light in a wide auditorium, symbolizing arts renovation. — The Sarasota Players have launched a 180-day fundraising campaign to complete renovations at the city-owned Payne Park Auditorium. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust local arts organizations to manage new donations effectively after prior financial losses?

The Sarasota Players launched a 180-day fundraising campaign on September 10, 2026, to finalize renovations at the city-owned Payne Park Auditorium. The initiative aims to secure a permanent home following a period of fiscal instability that included multi-million dollar losses.

Why it matters

The organization needs capital for essential lighting and sound equipment to stabilize operations after previous projects failed to materialize. This effort marks a strategic attempt to recover from years of significant financial decline.

The theater reported a $1.6 million loss in 2024, continuing a trend of negative net results that reached $4.8 million over the last four years. The group aims to raise $500,000 through the Payne Park Sprint campaign to fund facility upgrades.

The players

The Sarasota Players

This nonprofit community theater organization has operated for 97 seasons in Florida.

William Skaggs

He is the former CEO whose position was eliminated as part of a leadership restructuring.

Sarasota City Commission

This local governing body manages municipal property and approved the 30-year lease agreement for the auditorium.

Muriel O'Neil

Her namesake fund provided a $1 million bequest to help establish the theater's new indoor performance space.

The details

The renovation project focuses on constructing interior walls for a box office, dressing rooms, and offices within the Payne Park Auditorium. This space will include an in-the-round performance area known as the Muriel O'Neil Theatre, supported by a $1 million bequest.

The theater sold its previous home for $9 million in 2018.
The Sarasota City Commission approved a 30-year lease in 2024.
The Payne Park Sprint fundraiser launched on September 10, 2026.
The theater hopes to debut 'The Producers' on January 7, 2027.

Philanthropy
Sept. 29
Sarasota Alliance Adopted Three-Year Strategic Plan
Apartments
Sept. 24
Aspire on 10th Opened in Sarasota Rosemary District
Opera
Sept. 29
Sarasota Opera Named PJ Albert Managing Director

Industry Dynamics

This effort follows a pattern set by the 2018 sale of the Sarasota Players property as the organization attempts to survive the depletion of those capital gains. The restructuring reflects a broader challenge faced by legacy regional theaters attempting to maintain permanent venues.

Community members can expect changes to venue accessibility as the theater transitions from its temporary site at the Crossings at Siesta Key to the permanent Payne Park location. The success of this campaign determines the timeline for future productions, including the planned season opener.

The takeaway

Legacy cultural institutions often face significant hurdles when attempting to transition to new long-term facilities after liquidating real estate assets. Supporters should monitor the organization's progress through the upcoming 180-day sprint to gauge the theater's operational viability.