Miami Beach to Vote on Suing Over Hotel Law
Commissioners will weigh a resolution challenging a state law that limits local control over demolition of two historic beachfront hotels.
Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in City Hall

Live Poll
In your area, are state laws limiting local control over development making things better or worse?
Miami Beach commissioners are scheduled to vote November 18 on a resolution to sue the state over the Resiliency and Safe Structures Act. The law constrains city oversight of a proposed 38-story redevelopment of the Savoy and Arlington hotels on Ocean Drive.
Why it matters
The resolution argues the state law impairs the city's ability to oversee historic preservation mandated under the National Historic Preservation Act. The outcome could shape how much authority Miami Beach retains over demolition and redevelopment in its historic districts.
The resiliency act exempts only buildings in historic districts recognized by the National Register of Historic Places before 2000, which the city's position relies on to argue the law undermines local preservation oversight. Whether a court would side with the city on that claim has not been determined.
The players
Miami Beach City Commission
The city's elected governing body, which will decide whether to authorize a lawsuit against the state over the resiliency act.
Alex Fernandez
Miami Beach vice mayor who is sponsoring the resolution to sue the state over the resiliency act.
Allied Partners
The developer proposing the 38-story redevelopment of the Savoy and Arlington hotels under the state law.
The details
Allied Partners proposes redeveloping the Savoy, completed in 1937, and the Arlington, finished in 1941, on the South of Fifth stretch of Ocean Drive. The project relies on the Live Local Act for its height, while the resiliency act permits demolition of aging coastal buildings that fall short of flood protection standards.
Timeline
1937: Savoy hotel completed.
1941: Arlington hotel finished.
2000: Cutoff year for the National Register historic district exception in the resiliency act.
November 18, 2026: Commission vote on the resolution to sue over the resiliency act.
Legal Context
Miami Beach's resolution frames the dispute as a conflict between the state resiliency act and the National Historic Preservation Act, which requires local oversight of historic properties. The state's Live Local Act, which lets developers build taller in exchange for affordable units, adds a second state-level layer shaping the same beachfront sites.
If the city sues and prevails, local control over demolition of older beachfront buildings could be preserved, affecting future redevelopment timelines. If the state law stands, owners of historic properties in the area may face fewer local restrictions on tearing down and rebuilding.
The takeaway
The November 18 vote will show whether Miami Beach is willing to litigate against state preemption to protect its historic hotels. Residents and property owners along Ocean Drive should watch how the outcome shapes future demolition and height decisions.
What happens next
Commissioners are scheduled to vote on the resolution to sue the state on November 18, 2026.
Further reading
For more on how commissioners are handling the dispute, see City Hall coverage of Miami Beach.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Real Deal New York.
Live Poll
In your area, are state laws limiting local control over development making things better or worse?










