Wisevoter

AM Best Cuts Courtesy Insurance Outlook to Negative

The rating agency lowered its long-term credit outlook for the auto warranty insurer after three years of underwriting losses.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Insurance

AM Best Cuts Courtesy Insurance Outlook to Negative

AM Best downgraded the long-term credit outlook for Courtesy Insurance Co. from stable to negative, citing underwriting losses over the last three years. The company, an auto warranty firm part of JM Family Enterprises, keeps an A (Excellent) financial strength rating.

Why it matters

The outlook change signals ongoing pressure on the insurer's underwriting results, though AM Best has noted the company's balance sheet remains strong. Dealers and customers relying on Courtesy's parts warranty programs will be watching whether mitigation efforts restore profitability.

AM Best moved Courtesy's long-term credit outlook from stable to negative while leaving its A (Excellent) financial strength rating in place. The size of the underwriting losses and the timeline for recovery were not disclosed in the available information.

The players

Courtesy Insurance Co.

An auto warranty firm that provides warranties and insurance for car dealers' parts warranty programs, launched in the 1980s and part of JM Family Enterprises.

AM Best

A credit rating agency that assigns financial strength and credit ratings to insurance companies and other financial institutions.

The details

AM Best announced the outlook change in a bulletin, pointing to underwriting losses over the last three years. The losses were attributed in part to supply chain disruptions, inflation and labor costs, while management says mitigation initiatives should improve results over the medium-to-long term.

Timeline

  1. November 20, 2026: AM Best downgraded Courtesy's long-term credit outlook.

  2. Over the last three years: Courtesy reported underwriting losses.

Market Dynamics

The outlook change reflects how AM Best's rating framework weighs multi-year underwriting performance against balance-sheet strength, a balance that determines how insurers are priced in credit markets. Courtesy's case illustrates how inflation and labor-cost pressure can erode underwriting results even at insurers with strong capital.

Car dealers and buyers who depend on Courtesy's parts warranty programs should keep an eye on whether the insurer's underwriting results improve. A negative outlook can influence the pricing and terms available to the dealers that rely on the company's coverage.

The takeaway

Insurers with strong balance sheets can still face negative rating actions when underwriting losses persist, so consumers and dealers should look at multi-year results, not just capital strength. Watching how mitigation plans translate into profitability will show whether the outlook shift holds.

Further reading

Explore more Insurance coverage tied to Deerfield Beach business and consumer news.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Journal.