Save the Garden Sues Clearwater Over Scientology Land Deal
A civic group is challenging the City Council's refusal to reverse its decision to give a Garden Avenue roadway to the Church of Scientology.
Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Politics

Live Poll
Should residents be able to force a public vote on city land deals?
Save the Garden filed suit against the City of Clearwater after the City Council voted 3-2 not to act on a petition with 7,577 verified signatures seeking to reverse its decision to give South Garden Avenue roadway to the Church of Scientology. The church has broken ground on an auditorium and plaza named after L. Ron Hubbard on that block.
Why it matters
The council's refusal to put the question to voters as a referendum, and its reliance on advice from the Florida Attorney General's Office, puts a state-law limit on citizen petitions in the spotlight for Clearwater residents. The outcome of the suit will determine whether residents have a binding say over how public land is used.
The City Council voted 3-2 not to act on a petition carrying 7,577 verified signatures, a count the petition's sponsors say met the threshold to challenge the decision. Whether the court will order a special election or halt construction remains unresolved.
The players
Save the Garden
A local civic group that gathered the petition signatures and brought the lawsuit against the city seeking a special election and a halt to construction.
City of Clearwater
The Florida municipality whose City Council made the decision to give the South Garden Avenue roadway to the church and declined to reverse it.
Church of Scientology
The religious organization founded by L. Ron Hubbard, which has broken ground on an auditorium and plaza named after him on the block.
The details
The City Council declined to act on the petition and declined to put the question to voters as a referendum, following advice from the Florida Attorney General's Office. City Attorney Owen Kohler said repealing the decision would violate a state law barring citizen petitions from changing certain land development policies, and the Church of Scientology praised the council's decision in a statement.
Timeline
Week before November 13, 2026: Save the Garden filed suit against the city following the Council vote.
November 6, 2026: The City Council voted 3-2 not to act on the petition.
Political Context
The council's position rests on Florida law restricting citizen petitions from changing certain land development policies, and the opposition argues that residents' petition rights should prevail over that restriction. Save the Garden's lawsuit asks a court to decide whether that state limit applies to this decision.
Residents of Clearwater may find that petitions with enough verified signatures still do not force a council vote or a public referendum under current Florida law. The outcome of the lawsuit will determine whether that limit applies to future land-use decisions in the city.
The takeaway
A petition's signature count does not guarantee a public vote, because state law can limit what citizen petitions may change. Residents who want a say in land-use decisions should check which powers apply before organizing a petition.
Further reading
For more on how residents shape local decisions, see Civic Engagement coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Axios.
Live Poll
Should residents be able to force a public vote on city land deals?






