Kaduk DUI Trial Opens With Jury Selection
Cape Coral Councilmember Rachel Kaduk pleaded not guilty to driving under the influence and refusing a breathalyzer test as testimony began.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Politics

Live Poll
Do you trust local elected officials to face the same DUI consequences as everyone else?
Jury selection and testimony began Tuesday in the DUI trial of Cape Coral Councilmember Rachel Kaduk, who is accused of refusing to submit to a breathalyzer test after a December 2025 traffic stop. Kaduk has pleaded not guilty, and her defense argued she was willing to submit to a test.
Why it matters
The case involves a sitting member of the Cape Coral City Council, and a conviction could carry jail time that would keep her from the upcoming special meeting and swearing-in of the new council. The outcome will affect public confidence in local elected officials facing criminal charges.
Kaduk faces charges of driving under the influence and refusing a breathalyzer test and has pleaded not guilty. The trial continues Wednesday morning with testimony from the arresting officers, Cape Coral Police Chief Anthony Sizemore, and a defense witness.
The players
Rachel Kaduk
A Cape Coral City Council member on trial for alleged driving under the influence and refusal of a breathalyzer test.
John Gunter
The mayor of Cape Coral, who testified that he saw Kaduk drink four drinks the night of the incident.
Anthony Sizemore
The Cape Coral Police Chief, expected to testify when the trial resumes Wednesday.
The details
Witnesses for the state include Councilmember Jennifer Nelson-Lastra, Mayor John Gunter, and Jane Curry, who called 911 the night of the incident and reported Kaduk was allegedly driving recklessly for nearly 20 minutes after leaving Oak and Stone. Defense attorney Joe Vicava questioned Gunter's account, noting he became a witness months after the traffic stop.
Timeline
December 2025: Police stopped Kaduk after reported reckless driving.
Tuesday, November 17, 2026: Jury selection and testimony began in the trial.
Wednesday morning: Trial continues with arresting officers and a defense witness.
Legislative Policy
The case tests Florida's implied-consent law, which treats refusal of a breath test as a separate offense from impaired driving itself. Its outcome will show how the statute applies when a public official disputes that they refused to be tested.
A conviction could remove a sitting councilmember from her seat and affect how the city conducts its upcoming swearing-in and council business. Residents should watch for the Wednesday testimony, when the arresting officers and Police Chief Anthony Sizemore are expected to take the stand.
The takeaway
Criminal charges against an elected official are unresolved until a verdict, and the trial's findings on the breath-test refusal will matter to how similar cases are handled locally. Readers should follow the verdict rather than the initial accusations.
Further reading
Explore more Legislative Policy coverage tied to local government in Cape Coral.
Source note: This article includes information reported by WBBH.
Live Poll
Do you trust local elected officials to face the same DUI consequences as everyone else?






