Judge Keeps Boulder Flock Camera Lawsuit Alive

A Boulder County judge refused to dismiss a class action challenging the Boulder Police Department's use of Flock license plate cameras.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Crime

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a single pole-mounted street camera housing at a quiet corner, set against a distant foothill ridgeline.
A Boulder County judge refused to dismiss a class action alleging the Boulder Police Department's Flock license-plate cameras violate state search protections. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should police be able to search license plate camera records without a warrant?

Boulder County Judge Michael Kotlarczyk declined to dismiss the lawsuit in an order issued November 18, 2026. The judge found plaintiffs plausibly alleged the Flock system violates the Colorado Constitution's protection against unreasonable searches.

Why it matters

The ruling allows plaintiffs' claims over warrantless access to camera images to proceed toward trial. It also holds that Boulder cannot use its Flock contract to avoid obligations under the Colorado Criminal Justice Records Act.

The case is in active civil litigation after Judge Michael Kotlarczyk refused to dismiss it on November 18, 2026. Plaintiffs' attorney Andy McNulty hopes the matter goes to a jury trial next year, though no trial date has been set.

The players

Boulder Police Department

The Boulder law enforcement agency that contracts with Flock to operate license plate cameras at 31 monitored intersections.

Stephen Redfearn

The Boulder Police Chief named as a defendant in the class action challenging the city's use of Flock cameras.

Dawn VanAckeren

A defendant named alongside Boulder Police Chief Stephen Redfearn in the lawsuit over Flock camera data access.

The details

Plaintiffs William Freeman and Gwen Steel sued Boulder Police Chief Stephen Redfearn and Dawn VanAckeren, alleging the Flock system photographs every passing vehicle, including bicycles, and that its Vehicle Journey Map feature shows everywhere a vehicle was photographed over a chosen period. Freeman asked the department on December 23, 2025, for images of his own vehicle, but the department said running the search would violate its policy and contractual obligations.

Timeline

  1. December 23, 2025: William Freeman requested images of his vehicle captured by Flock cameras from the Boulder Police Department.

  2. November 18, 2026: Judge Michael Kotlarczyk refused to dismiss the class action lawsuit.

Legal Context

The ruling applies the Colorado Criminal Justice Records Act to a private vendor contract, testing how state transparency law reaches police surveillance technology. The Colorado Constitution's search protection is being applied to automated license plate camera networks.

Boulder residents driving past the 31 monitored intersections are having their vehicles photographed and stored for 30 days. The lawsuit's outcome could determine whether officers may search that stored data without a warrant.

The takeaway

Residents concerned about how their vehicle data is stored and searched can follow the lawsuit's progress as it moves toward a possible jury trial. The case may clarify whether public records laws apply to surveillance contracts with private vendors.

Further reading

For more on how police agencies use surveillance tools, see Law Enforcement coverage.

Live Poll

Should police be able to search license plate camera records without a warrant?