Senate Confirms Domenico to 10th Circuit Court
The 51-46 vote fills a seat vacated by Judge Timothy Tymkovich, with Colorado's Democratic senators voting against.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Elections

Live Poll
Do you trust federal judges appointed by the president to be impartial?
The U.S. Senate confirmed Judge Daniel Domenico to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals by a 51-46 vote. Colorado Senators Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, both Democrats, voted against the confirmation.
Why it matters
The seat opened when Judge Timothy Tymkovich moved to senior status, and Domenico's confirmation shifts the court's composition. Hickenlooper's office said Domenico's refusal to answer a 2020 election question during a judiciary committee hearing, and his record on immigration, were troubling and inconsistent with the standards expected of federal judges.
The Senate voted 51-46 to confirm Domenico, a seat vacated when Judge Timothy Tymkovich moved to senior status. Trump will nominate a replacement for Domenico on Colorado's federal district court, but no nominee has been named.
The players
Daniel Domenico
Domenico is a federal judge from Colorado who was confirmed to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals after previously serving as a district judge and as Colorado's solicitor general.
John Hickenlooper
Hickenlooper is a Democratic U.S. senator from Colorado and former governor of the state who voted against Domenico's confirmation.
Michael Bennet
Bennet is a Democratic U.S. senator from Colorado who voted against Domenico's confirmation.
Timothy Tymkovich
Tymkovich is a federal appeals judge whose move to senior status created the vacancy Domenico filled on the 10th Circuit.
The details
Domenico previously clerked for Judge Timothy Tymkovich in 2003 and served as Colorado's solicitor general. Trump first nominated him to the U.S. District Court of Colorado in 2017 and nominated him to the 10th Circuit in May. Domenico briefly served as chief judge of the Colorado district in 2026.
Timeline
2003: Domenico clerked for Judge Timothy Tymkovich.
2017: Trump nominated Domenico to the U.S. District Court of Colorado.
2022: Domenico had the fourth-biggest backlog of pending motions nationally.
May 2026: Trump nominated Domenico to the 10th Circuit.
November 17, 2026: The Senate confirmed Domenico to the 10th Circuit.
Political Context
Hickenlooper's office argued that Domenico's refusal to answer the 2020 election question and his immigration record fell short of the standards expected of federal judges. That objection, raised by Colorado's Democratic senators, is the main partisan pushback to a confirmation that otherwise cleared the Senate.
The 10th Circuit hears federal appeals from Colorado, Oklahoma, Kansas, New Mexico, Wyoming, and Utah, so Domenico's seat affects rulings that reach residents across those states. The forthcoming district court vacancy in Colorado will shape which federal judges hear local civil and criminal cases.
The takeaway
Judicial confirmations often hinge on senators' views of a nominee's answers during hearings, so readers following the Colorado district vacancy should watch the next nomination and its committee hearing. Track Senate votes on federal judges through official congressional records.
What happens next
Trump is expected to nominate a replacement for Domenico on Colorado's federal district court, though no date or nominee has been announced.
Further reading
For more on how judicial appointments intersect with state politics, see Elections coverage across Colorado.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Colorado Newsline.
Live Poll
Do you trust federal judges appointed by the president to be impartial?






