Tenth Circuit Revives EEOC Disability Suit Against Appliance Factory
A federal appeals court reversed a lower court ruling in favor of the Colorado retailer and sent the case back for further proceedings.
Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Human Resources

Live Poll
Do you trust employers to fairly handle workers' medical leave and disability requests?
The Tenth Circuit reversed a lower court decision favoring Appliance Factory and remanded the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's Americans with Disabilities Act case on behalf of a former sales associate. The worker was terminated on June 10, 2020, after her Family and Medical Leave Act leave expired.
Why it matters
The appellate ruling holds that a formal diagnosis is not required to put an employer on notice of a disability, a point that could shape how Colorado employers handle leave requests and accommodation obligations. The decision reopens claims of failure to accommodate, discrimination and retaliation.
The worker received twelve weeks of FMLA leave that expired June 8, 2020, two days before her June 10 termination letter. She had joined the Thornton, Colorado store as a sales associate in February 2019.
The players
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
The federal agency that enforces workplace anti-discrimination laws, including the Americans with Disabilities Act, and brought the suit on the worker's behalf.
Appliance Factory
A retail chain whose Thornton, Colorado store employed the worker and whose leave decision is at the center of the case.
The details
The worker's doctor scheduled an endoscopy in May 2020 and advised her to stay off work pending results, and she asked for a few additional weeks to recover after the procedure. An HR specialist suggested on June 9 that she resign if unable to return, and the June 10 letter said the company could not extend leave for a non-COVID condition. The endoscopy later confirmed mild gastritis.
Timeline
February 2019: Worker joins Appliance Factory as a sales associate in Thornton.
March 2020: FMLA leave of twelve weeks is granted.
June 8, 2020: FMLA leave expires.
June 10, 2020: Termination letter is issued.
November 6, 2026: Tenth Circuit reverses the lower court ruling.
Legal Context
The Tenth Circuit's holding that a formal diagnosis is not required to alert an employer to a disability builds on the Americans with Disabilities Act's accommodation framework and sets a notice standard that Colorado employers will now need to apply when leave runs out. The decision places the case squarely within the ADA's requirement that employers consider reasonable accommodations for employees with medical conditions.
Colorado workers who need medical leave may face the same question of whether an employer must extend leave beyond the FMLA period when a condition is not yet diagnosed. Employees should document medical recommendations and any requests for more time in writing.
The takeaway
Employers should treat a medical leave request as notice of a possible disability even before a diagnosis is confirmed, and document how they weigh any extension. Workers who need more time should request it in writing and keep a record of their medical advice.
Further reading
For related workplace rules, see Human Resources coverage on Wisevoter.
Live Poll
Do you trust employers to fairly handle workers' medical leave and disability requests?









