Judge Dismisses Santa Monica Voting Rights Suit

A Los Angeles County judge granted the city's motion in a case alleging its citywide election system dilutes Latino voting power.

Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Politics

Flat-color editorial illustration of a plain wooden ballot box standing alone in a sunlit plaza, navy and cream palette, evoking the contested city council election system.
A Los Angeles County judge dismissed a suit alleging Santa Monica's citywide council elections dilute Latino voting power, citing a recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think your city's elections give all residents a fair voice?

Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Daniel M. Crowley granted Santa Monica's motion for judgment on the pleadings on October 16 in a lawsuit alleging the city's citywide election of all seven councilmembers unlawfully dilutes Latino voting power. Plaintiffs' attorney Kevin Shenkman has said he intends to appeal the ruling.

Why it matters

The ruling relies on the U.S. Supreme Court's Louisiana v. Callais decision, which the city argued affects whether plaintiffs can prevail without proving intentional discrimination. The outcome could shape how Santa Monica elects its council and how similar challenges are handled in California courts.

The case has moved through a 2019 trial-court ruling for plaintiffs, a 2020 appellate reversal, and a 2023 California Supreme Court decision returning it for reconsideration. The October 16 ruling is the latest step, and the final judgment has not appeared on the docket.

The players

City of Santa Monica

The coastal Los Angeles County city, which elects all seven councilmembers citywide and is the defendant in the voting rights suit.

Daniel M. Crowley

The Los Angeles County Superior Court judge who granted the city's motion for judgment on the pleadings.

Kevin Shenkman

The attorney representing the plaintiffs, who has indicated he intends to appeal the ruling.

The details

The Pico Neighborhood Association and resident Maria Loya filed the suit in April 2016 over Santa Monica's citywide election of its seven councilmembers. The city's motion was granted after an October 16 hearing, and its proposed order cites the federal Louisiana v. Callais ruling issued April 29.

Timeline

  1. April 2016: Pico Neighborhood Association and Maria Loya filed the lawsuit against the city.

  2. 2019: Judge Yvette Palazuelos ruled for plaintiffs and ordered a seven-district election system.

  3. 2020: A state appellate court overturned the 2019 judgment.

  4. 2023: The California Supreme Court returned the case for reconsideration under a less restrictive standard.

  5. October 16: Judge Daniel M. Crowley granted the city's motion for judgment on the pleadings.

Political Context

Santa Monica's argument rests on the U.S. Supreme Court's Louisiana v. Callais decision, which the city says changes whether plaintiffs must show intentional discrimination. Opponents of the ruling would argue that the plaintiffs' claims about diluted Latino voting power still deserve full consideration on the merits.

Santa Monica voters continue to elect all seven councilmembers citywide under the current system for now, since no final judgment has taken effect. If the appeal succeeds, the city could be required to move to district-based elections, changing which neighborhoods are represented on the council.

The takeaway

Local election rules can remain in place for years while courts revisit them, so residents should watch for a final judgment and any appeal filing. Changes to how councilmembers are chosen would depend on how the courts interpret the federal standard.

Further reading

For background on how local voting systems are organized and challenged, explore more in Civic Engagement.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Patch.

Live Poll

Do you think your city's elections give all residents a fair voice?