San Francisco Denies Federal Voter Data Request
City officials refuse to hand over noncitizen voter registration information to the federal administration.
Updated on Oct. 30, 2026 in Civic Engagement
Live Poll
Should cities be permitted to grant noncitizens the right to vote in local school board elections?
City Attorney David Chiu has formally refused a federal demand for the personal data of 441 noncitizen school board voters. This decision follows a federal judge's denial of a request to set aside 20,000 ballots amid investigations into electoral integrity.
Why it matters
The conflict highlights a national divide over local voting rights for noncitizens versus federal efforts to root out alleged election fraud. City officials maintain that providing the requested voter information would violate state and local laws protecting electoral privacy.
San Francisco maintains a local database for noncitizen voters, who participate only in school board races using separate registration forms. A federal judge recently rejected an administration motion to set aside 20,000 ballots in the ongoing investigation.
The players
David Chiu
He is the City Attorney for San Francisco who refused the federal administration's request for voter registration information.
Donald Trump
He is the current President of the United States whose administration initiated the federal investigation into noncitizen voting.
The details
The Trump administration recently announced charges against 28 noncitizen Californians for illegal voting or registration. Advocates report that eligible local noncitizens, who previously participated in elections such as the 2022 school board recall, now fear participating due to increased federal scrutiny.
Timeline
Voters approved Measure N in 2016.
A state appeals court upheld noncitizen voting authority in 2022.
The Department of Justice requested information from county registrars in October 2026.
City Attorney David Chiu refused the federal data demand on October 27, 2026.
A federal judge denied a ballot set-aside request on October 28, 2026.
Political Context
The federal investigation directly challenges the legal authority granted to the city by the 2016 passage of Measure N. Opposition to these local programs often centers on concerns that municipal voting policies undermine statewide standards for electoral integrity.
Residents currently registered under the noncitizen school board program may face uncertainty regarding the validity of their future ballots. The city's refusal to release data is designed to protect participants from federal disclosure, though legal challenges to the program remain active.
The takeaway
The ongoing dispute over noncitizen participation in school board elections emphasizes the friction between municipal autonomy and federal oversight. Eligible participants should monitor local guidance for any changes to registration requirements or ballot access.
Further reading
Learn more about local policy debates at Civic Engagement.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Kqed.
Live Poll
Should cities be permitted to grant noncitizens the right to vote in local school board elections?
