San Francisco Chronicle Restored Star Restaurant Ratings
The newspaper has revived its signature four-star rating system for dining reviews after an eight-year hiatus.
Updated on Oct. 1, 2026 in Dining Out
Live Poll
Do you find star ratings helpful for deciding which restaurants are worth your time and money?
The San Francisco Chronicle has officially brought back its star-based rating system for restaurant reviews. Restaurant critics MacKenzie Chung Fegan and Cesar Hernandez will head the new initiative, which returns to the publication after being discontinued in 2018.
Why it matters
The revived scale aims to provide readers with a standardized way to evaluate local dining options and determine value across the citys diverse culinary scene. By offering a common language for restaurant quality, the system assists diners in navigating the competitive San Francisco food market.
The new system utilizes a scale ranging from zero to four stars to classify dining establishments. This revival marks the return of a metric that was a staple of the publication for decades before its 2018 discontinuation.
The players
MacKenzie Chung Fegan
She is a restaurant critic who announced the return of the star rating system.
Cesar Hernandez
He is a restaurant critic who will co-author reviews for the publication.
San Francisco Chronicle
This is a major daily newspaper serving the San Francisco Bay Area.
The details
Critics MacKenzie Chung Fegan and Cesar Hernandez will co-author the reviews, which are designed to simplify the decision-making process for local restaurant-goers. The announcement of the system's return took place in front of an audience of 200 people at the Gray Area venue in San Francisco.
Timeline
The publication issued its final starred review in 2018.
MacKenzie Chung Fegan announced the system's revival on September 30, 2026.
The first new starred review is scheduled for publication on October 1, 2026.
Culture Shift
The newspaper's decision to restore the ratings marks a clear departure from the 2018 industry trend where many publications moved away from numerical star systems. This shift reflects a move back toward simplified, at-a-glance metrics in an increasingly crowded digital media landscape.
Diners can now use these ratings to quickly gauge the quality and value of restaurants before committing to a reservation. This system helps simplify weekly planning by providing a familiar, standardized benchmark for comparing different culinary experiences across San Francisco.
The takeaway
Readers should view these stars as one of many tools for evaluating dining experiences rather than an absolute indicator of quality. Comparing these new ratings against personal preferences will help diners get the most value out of the citys expansive restaurant landscape.
Further reading
For more on the local food scene, browse the Dining Out section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by San Francisco Chronicle.
Live Poll
Do you find star ratings helpful for deciding which restaurants are worth your time and money?
