Judge Barred Rental of San Francisco Murder Site

A court stopped the leasing of a home where a resident was allegedly killed in May.

Updated on Sept. 27, 2026 in Apartments

Bold flat-color editorial illustration depicting a quiet residential building facade, evoking the gravity of a legal dispute over property occupancy. — A San Francisco judge issued an injunction on Tuesday blocking the Chagniot 2007 Family Trust from leasing a residential property following a May murder. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should landlords be required to disclose a home's violent history to prospective tenants?

A San Francisco judge blocked the rental of an Outer Sunset property following a murder that occurred there on May 17, 2026. The home, owned by the Chagniot 2007 Family Trust, became the subject of a wrongful death lawsuit.

Why it matters

The lawsuit alleges that the owner murdered the victim to clear the property for sale, highlighting severe disputes over real estate occupancy. The court's intervention stops the property from being leased while the legal proceedings continue.

The property was initially listed for $8,000 per month in August before the price dropped to $6,300 in September. The three-bedroom home is the center of a legal dispute involving the alleged murder of 58-year-old Eric Bigone.

The players

Philippe Chagniot

He is a 68-year-old suspect charged with the murder of Eric Bigone.

Dino Bigone

He is the plaintiff who filed a wrongful death lawsuit regarding the incident.

Chagniot 2007 Family Trust

This is the legal entity that owns the rental property in the Outer Sunset neighborhood.

The details

The property broker currently discloses the alleged killing in the lease agreement provided to prospective tenants. A prospective renter identified the history of the home through an online search of property ownership records.

The Chagniot 2007 Family Trust was established in 2007.
Eric Bigone was killed on May 17, 2026.
The property entered the rental market on August 22, 2026.
The monthly rent was reduced to $6,300 in September 2026.

Culture Shift

This case highlights the growing conflict between California's mandatory disclosure laws for stigmatized properties and the expectations of prospective tenants. It underscores a shift where digital public records make it increasingly difficult for owners to obscure a home's history.

Local residents in the Outer Sunset neighborhood have stated they plan to inform any potential new tenants about the history of the property. This informal community monitoring adds an extra layer of social pressure for landlords managing properties with difficult pasts.

The takeaway

Prospective renters in high-demand markets should utilize public record searches to verify the history of any property before signing a lease. Transparency remains essential in real estate transactions, especially when a property is associated with legal or criminal proceedings.