Modesto Moves to Repeal Protest Mask Ban

Council waives first reading of amendments after a federal judge blocked enforcement of the city's face-covering restrictions.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Legislative Policy

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain civic building facade with rows of tall windows against a deep red field, with a single slate-gray pole, evoking institutional restraint.
The Modesto City Council waived first reading Tuesday on amendments to repeal its protest mask ban, after a federal judge blocked enforcement and the city faces roughly $824,613 in legal fees. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should your city be allowed to ban face coverings at protests?

The Modesto City Council waived the first reading of proposed amendments that would repeal the city's protest mask ban. The city is expected to pay approximately $824,613 in legal expenses and plaintiffs' attorneys' fees.

Why it matters

The changes follow months of criticism from residents and a federal judge's order blocking enforcement of the restrictions in June. The amendments still require final approval before taking effect for Modesto and its residents.

The American Civil Liberties Union sued Modesto in March, and a federal judge blocked enforcement of the challenged provisions in June. The city's total legal expenses and plaintiffs' attorneys' fees come to approximately $824,613, and the case is not yet fully resolved.

The players

Modesto City Council

The Modesto City Council is the elected legislative body governing the city of Modesto, California, and it voted to waive the first reading of the repeal amendments.

American Civil Liberties Union

The American Civil Liberties Union is a national nonprofit civil rights organization that litigates constitutional and civil liberties cases, and it sued Modesto over the protest restrictions.

The details

The ordinance restricted face coverings during protests and helmet use. The proposed amendments would eliminate restrictions on face coverings during peaceful protests, ease helmet restrictions and allow journalists to wear protective gear.

Timeline

  1. June 2025: Five people were arrested for wearing masks during an anti-ICE protest in downtown Modesto.

  2. March 2026: The American Civil Liberties Union sued Modesto challenging the city's restrictions.

  3. June 2026: A federal judge blocked enforcement of the challenged provisions.

  4. November 16, 2026: Council members waived the first reading of the repeal amendments during a Monday meeting.

Legal Context

The repeal grows directly out of the June 2025 anti-ICE protest in downtown Modesto, where five people were arrested for wearing masks under the ordinance. The city is now reversing course after the ACLU's federal challenge and a court order blocking enforcement.

Residents who wear face coverings at peaceful protests would no longer face city restrictions if the amendments take effect. Journalists would be permitted to wear protective gear under the proposed changes, which still require final council approval.

The takeaway

Local ordinances restricting protest conduct can be challenged in federal court, and cities may face substantial legal costs when they lose. Residents watching the final council vote will see whether the repeal takes effect as proposed.

Further reading

For more on how local councils handle ordinance changes, see Legislative Policy coverage for Modesto.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CBS News.

Live Poll

Should your city be allowed to ban face coverings at protests?