Judge Orders Amended Claims in Brentwood Teacher Suit
A Los Angeles Superior Court judge found most claims in a former math teacher's suit against Brentwood School must be amended.
Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Law

Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Jeffery McFarland ruled that former Brentwood School math teacher Amy Page must add facts supporting most of her causes of action against the private K-12 school. Page may proceed with her California Family Rights Act discrimination and retaliation claims, and her attorneys have 45 days to file an amended complaint.
Why it matters
The ruling lets Page's family-leave discrimination and retaliation claims move forward while requiring more factual detail on the rest, shaping how a private employer in Los Angeles must respond to claims tied to medical leave. The case is at an early pleading stage, so its outcome remains open.
The court allowed Page's California Family Rights Act discrimination and retaliation claims to proceed while requiring additional factual support for most other causes of action. Whether the amended complaint will survive further challenge has not been determined.
The players
Brentwood School
Brentwood School is a private K-12 independent school in Los Angeles, and it is the defendant in this employment lawsuit.
Jeffery McFarland
Jeffery McFarland is a Los Angeles Superior Court judge who ruled on the pleadings in Page's lawsuit against the school.
The details
Page alleges Brentwood School removed her upper-level courses and placed her on performance improvement plans beginning in fall 2023, and that she was terminated while on medical leave because of her age and health and in retaliation for taking leave. Judge McFarland found her California Family Rights Act claims sufficiently connect her return from leave to a notice that her employment would not be renewed. The suit also alleges the head of school's non-renewal notice was motivated by Page's age, health and medical leave.
Timeline
2008: Page hired by Brentwood School.
Fall 2023: Alleged discrimination began with course removals and performance plans.
March 2024: Page filed a written complaint with the upper school director.
October 2024: Page placed on medical leave.
June 30, 2025: Page terminated.
Legal Context
The ruling reflects how California courts evaluate employer claims under the California Family Rights Act, where a link between medical leave and a later non-renewal notice can support a claim at the pleading stage. Similar medical-leave retaliation suits are typically tested on whether the complaint pleads specific facts connecting leave to the adverse action.
Employees who take medical leave in California may be protected from retaliation under the California Family Rights Act, and documenting complaints and leave dates can matter in later disputes. Employers reviewing non-renewal decisions after leave should be aware that such claims can proceed to litigation.
The takeaway
Claims tied to medical leave can survive early challenge when the complaint connects the leave to a specific adverse decision, so employees should keep records of complaints, leave dates and performance actions. The case will turn on whether the amended complaint supplies the missing facts.
What happens next
Page's attorneys have 45 days to file an amended complaint, after which Brentwood School is expected to respond to the revised claims.
Further reading
For more on related court rulings, browse the Law section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by My News LA.






