Judge Rejects Cosby Challenge to Trial Tech Bill

Los Angeles Superior Court ruled on expenses tied to the civil case in which a California jury sided with Donna Motsinger.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Sex Crimes

Judge Rejects Cosby Challenge to Trial Tech Bill

Live Poll

Should losing parties in civil cases always pay the full cost of trial expenses?

On October 9, 2026, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Bradley S. Phillips rejected Bill Cosby's challenge to a $36,870 courtroom technology bill from Executive Presentations, Inc. The judge also reduced Donna Motsinger's recoverable lodging expenses from $11,904.24 to $7,500.

Why it matters

The ruling determines which trial costs Cosby must reimburse in a case where a California jury previously sided with Motsinger in March 2026. The $59 million judgment remains subject to appellate proceedings.

The court ordered Cosby to answer additional written questions and imposed $1,560 in sanctions, while the $59 million judgment remains subject to appellate review. A hearing on Motsinger's contempt and sanctions requests is scheduled for January 19, 2027.

The players

Bill Cosby

Former entertainer whose civil sexual assault judgment of $59 million remains subject to appellate proceedings.

Donna Motsinger

Plaintiff who won a civil jury verdict against Bill Cosby in California in March 2026.

Bradley S. Phillips

Los Angeles Superior Court judge who ruled on the trial expense challenges in the case.

The details

Cosby's attorneys challenged the expenses in an October 2 filing, arguing that Motsinger's lawyers could have read the deposition questions and answers aloud instead of playing video. Judge Phillips concluded the video was important because Cosby did not attend the trial and jurors could evaluate his demeanor through it.

Timeline

  1. March 2026: California jury sided with Motsinger against Cosby.

  2. October 2, 2026: Cosby's legal team filed its challenge to the technology bill.

  3. October 9, 2026: Judge Phillips rejected the video expense challenge and reduced lodging costs.

  4. January 19, 2027: Hearing scheduled on Motsinger's contempt and sanctions requests.

Legal Context

The ruling follows the March 2026 California civil jury verdict in favor of Donna Motsinger against Bill Cosby. It shows how trial costs such as courtroom technology and lodging are scrutinized after a civil sexual assault verdict.

The ruling sets which trial costs Cosby must reimburse, affecting the financial outcome for the parties in a closed jury trial. It also shows that trial presentation choices, such as video depositions, can be recovered as costs when a defendant does not appear in person.

The takeaway

Courts weigh whether trial technology was necessary before awarding those costs to the winning party. Readers following civil sexual assault cases can track how post-verdict expense rulings shape final financial outcomes.

What happens next

A hearing on Donna Motsinger's contempt and sanctions requests is scheduled for January 19, 2027.

Further reading

For more background on related cases, see Sex Crimes coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by RadarOnline.

Live Poll

Should losing parties in civil cases always pay the full cost of trial expenses?