Court Bars Hospital Lien on Medi-Cal Patient Settlement
A California appeals court ruled that Long Beach Memorial Medical Center cannot place a lien on a Medi-Cal patient's injury settlement.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Industry

Live Poll
Do you trust hospitals to bill fairly when patients have injury settlements?
The Second Appellate District of the California Court of Appeal ruled that Long Beach Memorial Medical Center cannot place a hospital lien on a Medi-Cal patient's injury settlement. The appeals court reversed a lower court's dismissal and sent an unfair competition claim back to proceed.
Why it matters
The decision limits how hospitals in Long Beach and across California can recover unpaid charges from patients covered by Medi-Cal, the state's health program for low-income residents. It also keeps the underlying class action allegations alive without resolving their merits.
The hospital did not submit $7,683 in charges to Medi-Cal, while the patient settled her injury claim for $7,500 in March 2021. The court's decision does not resolve the merits of the class action allegations covering the four years before the original complaint.
The players
Long Beach Memorial Medical Center
A hospital in Long Beach, California, that is part of a larger regional healthcare system serving the Long Beach area.
Alliance United
The insurer of the at-fault driver in the 2020 car accident, which held the patient's settlement money because of the hospital lien.
The details
The patient, injured in a June 2020 car accident, presented a Medi-Cal card at the hospital's front desk two days after the crash. The hospital billed Medi-Cal for part of her treatment but mailed a lien notice to Alliance United, the at-fault driver's insurer, after failing to submit the remaining charges. The court held that a hospital accepting Medi-Cal must bill through the program and accept Medi-Cal rates as full payment.
Timeline
June 2020: Patient injured in a car accident.
Two days after the accident: Patient arrives at Long Beach Memorial Medical Center.
2005: California Supreme Court issues the Parnell decision.
March 2021: Patient settles her injury claim for $7,500.
November 16, 2026: Second Appellate District rules against the hospital lien.
Healthcare Financing Context
The ruling turns on the boundary between California's Hospital Lien Act, which lets hospitals lien injury settlements only when a patient owes them money, and the Medi-Cal Act, which reserves reimbursement claims for the state. The decision follows the 2005 California Supreme Court Parnell decision on hospital lien practices.
Medi-Cal patients who receive hospital care after an accident may be protected from having their injury settlements held back by hospital liens. The ruling may affect how Long Beach hospitals bill for treatment covered by the state program.
The takeaway
Patients enrolled in Medi-Cal should confirm that providers bill the program for covered care. Those facing a hospital lien notice after an injury can ask whether the hospital is following the limits the court described.
Further reading
For related coverage, explore Healthcare news from Long Beach.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Business.
Live Poll
Do you trust hospitals to bill fairly when patients have injury settlements?






