Court Bars Hotel From Forcing Pregnancy Claim Into Arbitration

A California appellate court ruled a former Beverly Hills hotel worker's pregnancy harassment claim cannot be sent to private arbitration under federal law.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Business

Court Bars Hotel From Forcing Pregnancy Claim Into Arbitration

Live Poll

Should workers be able to take discrimination claims to court rather than private arbitration?

California's Second Appellate District blocked a luxury hotel in Beverly Hills from forcing a former guest reception manager's pregnancy harassment claim into private arbitration. The November 17, 2026 ruling held that the federal Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act covers gender and pregnancy harassment claims.

Why it matters

The decision is certified for publication and binds California trial courts, potentially limiting employers' use of arbitration clauses in harassment cases. The court found the federal law's plain text is not confined to the #MeToo-era context in which Congress passed it.

The worker spent nearly nine years as a guest reception manager before being terminated in January 2024, five days after a false accusation was made against her. The ruling resolves only the forum question, sending the case toward court rather than arbitration, while the merits of her claims remain undecided.

The players

Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act

A federal law enacted in 2022 that allows workers to bring sexual harassment and sexual assault claims to court despite pre-dispute arbitration agreements.

California Second Appellate District

The California appellate court whose published decision on this matter is binding on state trial courts.

The details

The worker disclosed her first pregnancy in October 2020 and was later never interviewed for a director-level position, which the hotel filled with a man. She filed suit in March 2024 under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act, and the court relied on that statute's definition of sex, which includes gender and pregnancy, to interpret the federal arbitration law.

Timeline

  1. October 2020: Worker disclosed her first pregnancy to her employer.

  2. December 2023: A regional director told the worker to stop seeking promotions.

  3. January 2024: The worker was terminated.

  4. March 2024: The worker filed suit under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act.

  5. November 17, 2026: The Second Appellate District issued its ruling.

Legal Context

The ruling extends the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act beyond the sexual misconduct claims it was largely understood to cover, applying it to gender and pregnancy harassment under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act. The court explicitly rejected the hotel's argument that the law reaches only lewd or lascivious conduct.

Employees in California facing harassment claims may find that arbitration clauses are less likely to force their disputes into private proceedings. Workers who believe they were treated unfairly for pregnancy or gender should understand that courts may now hear such claims even when an arbitration agreement exists.

The takeaway

Pregnancy and gender harassment claims may fall within federal protections that let workers take disputes to court rather than private arbitration. Employees who face retaliation after reporting such treatment should document the timeline of events closely.

Further reading

Explore more Human Resources coverage to see how workplace harassment and arbitration rules are evolving.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Human Resources Director.

Live Poll

Should workers be able to take discrimination claims to court rather than private arbitration?