Court Lets Clinic Privacy Suit Proceed Over Tracking Tools

A federal judge in California denied a motion to dismiss a claim that a cosmetic clinic's website tracking tools read patient communications.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Cybersecurity

Court Lets Clinic Privacy Suit Proceed Over Tracking Tools

Live Poll

Do you trust websites to keep your health information private when you browse?

The U.S. District Court for the Central District of California denied a motion to dismiss the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) claim in Ferlej v. Pertrosian Esthetic Enterprises. The plaintiff, Nicole Ferlej, alleges the tracking tools on a cosmetic clinic's website read and transmitted her communications as she filled out a patient form.

Why it matters

The ruling allows a privacy claim over website tracking tools to move forward, which bears on how businesses that collect health-related information online may be held liable under California law. Whether the tools read communications in transit remains a central question for the case.

The court denied the defendants' motion to dismiss the CIPA claim, which was the only claim challenged, so the case proceeds past the pleading stage. The filing is case No. 2:26-cv-0130-MWC-AGR, and the plaintiff's second amended complaint is the operative pleading.

The players

Nicole Ferlej

The plaintiff in the case, who filed the second amended complaint alleging the website's tracking tools read her communications.

U.S. District Court for the Central District of California

The federal trial court in Los Angeles that handles civil cases across Southern California and issued the ruling in this matter.

The details

The plaintiff alleges that tracking tools on a cosmetic clinic's website read the specific treatment she sought and her reason for seeking it. The court found she plausibly alleged the tools read the actual content of her interaction with the website, not merely metadata. The defendant argued the plaintiff failed to plausibly allege that communications were read while in transit.

Timeline

  1. November 12, 2026: The Central District of California issued the order denying the motion to dismiss.

Legal Context

The decision applies California's wiretapping statute to web tracking technology, following a growing line of CIPA suits against website operators over third-party tools. Courts in California have been divided on how far the in-transit requirement reaches, making this ruling a notable data point in that debate.

Californians who share health or personal details through online forms may have privacy protections under CIPA that can support claims against businesses. Consumers can review website privacy policies and cookie settings before submitting sensitive information.

The takeaway

Online form submissions may be monitored by third-party tracking tools, so reviewing a site's privacy practices before sharing health information is a practical step. Courts are still defining how California's wiretap law applies to these tools.

Further reading

Explore more cybersecurity coverage on how online privacy laws are shaping data collection practices in California.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The National Law Review - A Free To Use Nationwide Database of Legal Publications.

Live Poll

Do you trust websites to keep your health information private when you browse?