Judge Orders Blenman Elm, Church to Consider Mediation
A Tucson civil lawsuit over church services for homeless residents moves toward a possible settlement conference.
Updated on Nov. 15, 2026 in Christianity
Live Poll
Do you think homeless services in your neighborhood have made it less safe?
Pima County Superior Court Judge Cynthia Kuhn ordered residents of Blenman Elm and Grace St. Paul's Episcopal Church to decide whether they are willing to try mediation or a settlement conference. The case stems from a lawsuit filed by Friends of Blenman-Elm in January, which seeks a preliminary injunction against services the church provides at 2331 E. Adam's St.
Why it matters
The lawsuit tests whether services for homeless and needy people can be treated as a legal nuisance under Arizona law, a question with implications for neighborhoods across Tucson. The outcome may shape how the church and nearby residents address safety concerns in midtown.
The church's services, known collectively as Joseph's Pantry, take place three times per week at 2331 E. Adam's St. The Nov. 5 hearing featured sworn testimony, but the court has not yet ruled on the request for an injunction.
The players
Grace St. Paul's Episcopal Church
A Tucson congregation that runs Joseph's Pantry, a set of services for homeless and needy people, and is the defendant in the lawsuit.
Cynthia Kuhn
A judge of the Pima County Superior Court who ordered the parties to consider mediation or a settlement conference.
The details
Residents testified about violent threats, open drug use, homeless people sleeping on private property, and fires near the church. The church's priest described security services, daily trash cleanups, bans on drug users, and the moving of encampments as measures the church has taken.
Timeline
January 2026: Friends of Blenman-Elm filed the lawsuit against the church.
Nov. 5, 2026: A court hearing was held with sworn resident testimony.
Friday, Nov. 13, 2026: Judge Kuhn ordered the parties to consider mediation or a settlement conference.
Legal Context
The complaint applies Arizona's public nuisance doctrine to a church's social services, a use of the doctrine that is less common than disputes over bars or industrial sites. How Judge Kuhn resolves the dispute may clarify whether charitable services fall within that doctrine.
Residents near Blenman Elm and 2331 E. Adam's St. may see changes to how church services are run, including security and encampment policies. The outcome could affect how nearby neighborhoods handle services for homeless residents.
The takeaway
Disputes over social services in neighborhoods often turn on safety concerns and property use, and mediation may offer a path for residents and providers to find common ground. Watching how this case resolves may offer insight into similar tensions elsewhere in Tucson.
What happens next
The parties must respond to the judge's order on whether they will pursue mediation or a settlement conference.
Further reading
For more on faith communities in the region, explore Christianity coverage on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Arizona Daily Star.
Live Poll
Do you think homeless services in your neighborhood have made it less safe?
