City, Desert Mountain Energy Hold Settlement Talks

Attorneys for Flagstaff and Desert Mountain Energy met on November 3 to explore resolving a helium-related water dispute without trial.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Business

Wide high-desert plateau of ochre grassland and juniper under a clear sky, with a single small steel drilling rig on the distant horizon.
Attorneys for the City of Flagstaff and Desert Mountain Energy held settlement talks on November 3 over helium drilling that the city says threatens the Red Gap Ranch aquifer. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Attorneys for the City of Flagstaff and Desert Mountain Energy held a settlement conference on November 3 over the city's lawsuit concerning helium extraction near Red Gap Ranch. A joint filing to the U.S. District Court for Arizona described the talks as productive, though no formal settlement agreement was reached.

Why it matters

The dispute centers on whether drilling and extraction could threaten the aquifer beneath Red Gap Ranch, a water source the city bought for its groundwater rights. The outcome could shape how Flagstaff protects its long-term water supply from energy development.

The city bought Red Gap Ranch in 2005 for its groundwater rights and has not pumped any water from the property, while the lawsuit against Desert Mountain Energy was filed in December 2020. Whether the company's operations would affect the aquifer beneath the ranch remains disputed and unresolved.

The players

Desert Mountain Energy

A Canadian-based company engaged in helium, hydrogen, and natural gas production, holding multiple land leases in Arizona and New Mexico.

The details

The city alleges that Desert Mountain's drilling and extraction operations would threaten the aquifer beneath Red Gap Ranch, while the company maintains they would not. The city has said it someday plans to build a lengthy pipeline to carry water from the ranch to supply the Navajo and Hopi tribes.

Timeline

  1. December 2020: The City of Flagstaff sued Desert Mountain Energy.

  2. 2005: The city purchased Red Gap Ranch for its groundwater rights.

  3. November 3: Attorneys held a settlement conference.

  4. Late January: A second settlement conference is scheduled.

Market Landscape

The dispute reflects a broader contest in the Southwest between municipal groundwater claims and expanding energy extraction, as companies seek helium and natural gas across Arizona and New Mexico. How the court and the parties resolve the aquifer question could influence how other growing cities guard water rights against similar drilling projects.

Flagstaff residents who depend on the city's water system have a direct stake in whether the aquifer beneath Red Gap Ranch is protected for future municipal use. The result could affect long-term water planning and the cost of building any future pipeline to supply surrounding communities.

The takeaway

Water rights purchased decades ago can become central to modern energy disputes, making long-term groundwater planning a practical concern for growing cities. Readers following the case should watch the late January conference for any movement toward a formal agreement.

What happens next

Attorneys for the city and Desert Mountain Energy are scheduled to hold a second settlement conference in late January.

Further reading

For related coverage, explore Oil and Gas reporting on the energy industry's expansion across the region.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Arizona Daily Sun.