Tiny Tim's Pizza Faced Eviction Notice

The local restaurant must vacate its Fayetteville square location by October 7.

Updated on Oct. 5, 2026 in Openings & Closings

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a historic brick storefront archway, representing the end of a long-standing local restaurant's lease. — Tiny Tim's Pizza must vacate its Fayetteville square location by October 7 after Hillcrest Holdings LLC issued an eviction notice. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should local governments enact stronger protections for long-term businesses facing sudden eviction by new landlords?

Hillcrest Holdings LLC has issued an eviction notice to Tiny Tim's Pizza following a missed rent payment. The restaurant, a fixture on the Fayetteville square since 1982, must vacate the premises at 21 W. Mountain St. by October 7, 2026.

Why it matters

The lease termination follows the building's acquisition by Hillcrest Holdings LLC earlier this year. The landlord cited a rent delinquency exceeding five days as the reason for the eviction.

The 6,094-square-foot restaurant space is now listed for lease at $18,789.83 per month. Hillcrest Holdings LLC previously purchased the building in January 2026 for $7 million.

The players

Tiny Tim's Pizza

This restaurant has operated on the Fayetteville square for over 40 years.

Hillcrest Holdings LLC

This real estate entity purchased the building at 21 W. Mountain St. in early 2026.

The details

Hillcrest Holdings LLC issued the notice on September 29, 2026, after the tenant failed to make a payment for more than five days. The company is actively marketing the space for a new tenant via the MLS.

April 1982: Tiny Tim's Pizza opened on the Fayetteville square.
January 2026: Hillcrest Holdings LLC purchased the property.
September 29, 2026: The tenant received the lease termination notice.
October 7, 2026: The deadline for the restaurant to vacate the building.

Market Landscape

This eviction follows a pattern set by increased commercial real estate consolidation in Fayetteville. The acquisition of the Mountain Street property by Hillcrest Holdings LLC aligns with broader local trends of shifting property ownership and rising commercial lease valuations.

Regular customers of Tiny Tim's Pizza should be aware that the restaurant faces imminent closure. Future retail options at the 21 W. Mountain St. location will depend on the terms reached between the landlord and potential new tenants.

The takeaway

Commercial property changes can lead to the displacement of long-standing community fixtures when lease obligations are not met. Business owners should maintain proactive communication with landlords to navigate shifting market conditions and rent obligations.