Judge Weighs Intellectual Disability Claim in Mobile Capital Case

Expert testimony in a Mobile County court addresses whether a capital murder defendant is barred from the death penalty.

Updated on Nov. 14, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a columned courthouse facade with a half-mast flag across an empty plaza, evoking a court weighing a death penalty question.
A Mobile County judge heard expert testimony Tuesday on whether a 22-year-old charged with capital murder has an intellectual disability that would bar the death penalty. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

A Mobile County circuit judge heard expert testimony on whether a 22-year-old man charged with capital murder has an intellectual disability that would bar the death penalty. Judge Vicki Davis did not immediately rule and allowed both sides to submit additional written arguments.

Why it matters

The case tests how Alabama courts apply the 2002 U.S. Supreme Court ruling barring execution of intellectually disabled defendants. The outcome could determine whether the death penalty remains available in a 2024 robbery case that left two people dead and two injured.

The defendant, a 22-year-old Mobile man, faces capital murder charges and a pending ruling on whether he is eligible for the death penalty. Judge Vicki Davis has not yet decided the intellectual disability question and has allowed additional written arguments from both sides.

The players

Vicki Davis

Mobile County Circuit Judge presiding over the capital case and the intellectual disability question. Davis has the authority to rule on whether the death penalty may be sought.

Mobile County District Attorney's Office

The prosecuting agency in Mobile County that has sought the death penalty seven times in the past five years. The office argues the defendant does not meet the legal standard for intellectual disability.

The details

Expert psychologist Stephen Zieman testified that the defendant scored 68 on an IQ test he administered in 2025 after reviewing school, mental health and jail records. A defense psychologist testified that adaptive functioning deficits appeared as early as age 5, while prosecutors cross-examined Zieman about earlier evaluations that rated the defendant's abilities higher. The crime occurred in a backyard barbershop on Euclid Avenue.

Timeline

  1. 2002: The U.S. Supreme Court barred the death penalty for intellectually disabled defendants.

  2. 2024: The robbery and killings occurred on Euclid Avenue in Mobile.

  3. 2025: Zieman administered the IQ test that produced a score of 68.

  4. Nov. 13, 2026: Judge Davis heard expert testimony on the intellectual disability claim.

Legal Context

The hearing applies the 2002 Atkins v. Virginia decision, which left states to set their own procedures for assessing intellectual disability and has produced ongoing litigation over IQ thresholds and adaptive functioning. Mobile County prosecutors' request for the death penalty in seven cases over five years places this ruling in the context of how the county pursues capital charges.

The ruling will determine whether the death penalty is available in this Mobile case, affecting how the county's court system handles capital charges. Residents following local criminal proceedings can track the judge's decision and any further hearings through the Mobile County court system.

The takeaway

Intellectual disability claims in capital cases turn on contested IQ scores and adaptive functioning evidence, making expert testimony central to whether a death sentence is legally available. Readers following similar cases can watch how judges weigh conflicting evaluations.

Further reading

Explore more Criminal Justice coverage from Mobile for context on how courts handle capital cases.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Fox10tv.