Pastor Entered Not Guilty Plea in Mobile Court
Robert Michael Wagley faces charges for allegedly employing a sex offender at a local church.
Updated on Oct. 13, 2026 in Crime — General

Robert Michael Wagley, 70, entered a formal plea of not guilty in Mobile County Circuit Court following criminal charges. He is accused of violating the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act and intimidating witnesses.
Why it matters
The legal case centers on allegations that the pastor improperly employed a convicted sex offender as a volunteer greeter at the St. Elmo Seventh-day Adventist Church. Legal proceedings will now determine if these actions warrant the charges filed by prosecutors.
Robert Michael Wagley faces one charge of violating the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act and three counts of witness intimidation. The defendant entered his not guilty plea on October 13, 2026, in Mobile County Circuit Court.
The players
Robert Michael Wagley
The 70-year-old pastor of the St. Elmo Seventh-day Adventist Church who faces criminal charges.
Jay York
The Mobile County Circuit Judge who is presiding over the criminal proceedings.
John Penrod II
A convicted sex offender whom prosecutors allege was given a volunteer greeter position by the defendant.
The details
Prosecutors claim Wagley allowed John Penrod II, a convicted sex offender, to serve as a volunteer greeter at the St. Elmo Seventh-day Adventist Church. During recent proceedings, Mobile County Circuit Judge Jay York denied a request from the defense to force prosecutors to provide a more granular description of the alleged offenses.
Timeline
Robert Michael Wagley entered his not guilty plea in court on October 13, 2026.
Legal Context
This case highlights the strict compliance requirements imposed by the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act on local institutions. The legal proceedings mirror a broader regional trend of increased scrutiny regarding the oversight of registered offenders in public-facing roles.
Residents may see continued activity at the local courthouse as this case proceeds through the legal system. The outcome will clarify the responsibilities of faith-based organizations when vetting volunteers who interact with the public.
The takeaway
This case serves as a reminder of the legal obligations institutions face when managing volunteers who are registered offenders. Proper vetting remains a critical step for maintaining community safety standards in public spaces.
Further reading
For additional updates on local legal proceedings, visit the Crime — General section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Fox10tv.










