Court Approves Order to Demolish Five Points Properties

A Jefferson County judge signed a consent order requiring the owner of three vacant Five Points South buildings to remove debris, secure them and demolish most of the structures.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in City Hall

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a weathered brick vacant building with boarded windows and a distant crane silhouette, in deep red and cream.
A Jefferson County judge signed a consent order requiring the owner of three vacant Five Points South buildings in Birmingham to secure and demolish most of them. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think problem vacant buildings in your neighborhood are getting better?

Jefferson County Circuit Judge Monica Agee signed a consent order on Nov. 16 resolving the City of Birmingham's lawsuit against a Five Points South property company. The lawsuit alleged the three vacant properties remained unsecured despite code violation notices.

Why it matters

The city's complaint cited fires, repeated police calls and a Nov. 1 shooting at the properties, and the order sets enforceable deadlines for securing and demolishing the buildings. The court will retain jurisdiction over the agreement, giving the city a path to enforce compliance for at least 18 months.

The consent order sets 15 days to remove debris, 30 days to secure entrances, 90 days to hire a licensed demolition firm and 120 days to finish demolition. Whether the owner meets these timelines has not yet been tested, and the first status report is due on or about Dec. 13.

The players

Monica Agee

Monica Agee is a Jefferson County Circuit Judge who signed the consent order resolving the city's lawsuit.

City of Birmingham

Birmingham is Alabama's largest city and the government that sued the property company and will oversee compliance with the order.

The details

Under the order, the owner must begin asbestos surveys the week of Nov. 16 and provide Birmingham with status reports every 30 days. If the requirements are met, the city will stop further legal action against the company and the properties.

Timeline

  1. Nov. 1: Shooting reported at the properties cited in the city's complaint.

  2. Nov. 5: City of Birmingham files lawsuit against the property company.

  3. Nov. 16: Judge Agee signs the consent order.

  4. Dec. 13: First status report due to the city.

Legal Context

The case follows Birmingham's use of civil lawsuits to compel owners of unsecured vacant buildings to act after code violation notices went unanswered. Court-supervised consent orders like this one give the city a binding enforcement tool that code citations alone do not provide.

Residents and businesses near Five Points South can expect demolition work, debris removal and building security changes over the next several months. The order gives the city court oversight to enforce those deadlines if the owner falls behind.

The takeaway

Unsecured vacant buildings can be pushed toward court-enforced remediation when code notices are ignored. Neighbors of similar properties can report unsafe conditions to the city so enforcement can begin early.

What happens next

The first status report to Birmingham is due on or about Dec. 13, and the owner must hire a licensed demolition firm within 90 days and complete demolition within 120 days.

Further reading

For more on how the city is handling local property enforcement, see City Hall coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by WBMA.

Live Poll

Do you think problem vacant buildings in your neighborhood are getting better?