Court Rules Hospital Unit Can't Claim Immunity
The Alabama Supreme Court reversed the dismissal of a malpractice suit over a patient's death at a University of South Alabama hospital.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Industry

The Alabama Supreme Court ruled on November 13 that USA Health Care Management cannot claim governmental immunity from a medical malpractice lawsuit. The court reversed a trial court's dismissal of the suit brought by Carol Brown Marsh over the death of her husband, Preston Marsh.
Why it matters
The ruling limits how a state-linked hospital management entity can use its legal structure to avoid liability while keeping its financial benefits. It bears on how patients across Alabama can pursue claims against hospital systems tied to public universities.
The Alabama Supreme Court opinion, issued November 13, rests on a legal structure that a state financial officer says saved the state more than $100 million. The opinion does not address how the savings figure was calculated or whether it would change the outcome of the malpractice claim.
The players
Alabama Supreme Court
The state's highest court for civil cases, based in Montgomery, Alabama, whose rulings set binding precedent for lower courts in the state.
University of South Alabama
A public university in Mobile, Alabama, whose hospital operations are managed through a separate corporate entity.
The details
USA Health Care Management was set up by the University of South Alabama as a limited liability corporation to manage its hospital and gain state and federal tax benefits. The court found the entity has no officers, directors or property and turns over its earnings to the state, and it held the entity cannot claim both private-LLC financial benefits and state-agency liability protection.
Timeline
November 13, 2026: Alabama Supreme Court issues opinion reversing dismissal of the Marsh suit.
Legal Context
The decision narrows the reach of Alabama's sovereign immunity doctrine, which shields state agencies from many lawsuits, by refusing to extend it to a corporate entity that seeks private financial advantages. It follows the general pattern of courts scrutinizing whether public institutions can split their legal identities to avoid accountability.
Patients treated at hospitals run through similar corporate structures may face uncertainty about whom to sue after an injury. The ruling clarifies that such entities cannot automatically rely on state immunity when they retain private-style financial benefits.
The takeaway
Public institutions that use separate corporate entities for financial advantages may not also be able to claim the immunity that comes with state status. Patients injured in such facilities should understand that legal protections depend on how the entity is actually structured.
Further reading
Explore more on Healthcare coverage across the state of Alabama.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Legal Newsline.






