Car Repair Costs Inflated by $12 Billion Yearly

PIRG says software access requirements and manufacturer fees are driving up vehicle repair and insurance costs across the United States.

Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Insurance

Empty automotive repair bay with a sedan raised on a hydraulic lift and a coiled diagnostic cable on the concrete floor.
PIRG estimates U.S. car repair costs are inflated by $12 billion a year, as software access requirements and manufacturer fees push independent shops toward authorized dealerships. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think your car repair costs have gotten higher over the past few years?

PIRG Education Fund estimated that US car repair costs are inflated by $12 billion each year due to computerized vehicle functions. The group also reported a two-tiered repair model now exists between independent shops and authorized dealerships.

Why it matters

Higher repair costs translate into higher insurance claims, which PIRG says drivers ultimately pay through insurance premiums. Independent repair shops face added expenses and reduced access to diagnostic information compared with authorized dealerships.

PIRG's estimate of 83 million mechanic hours a year spent on software access totals $12 billion at typical repair rates, while auto insurance prices have risen three times as fast as the rest of the US economy since 2012. The report does not detail how manufacturers or regulators are expected to respond.

The players

PIRG Education Fund

The Public Interest Research Group Education Fund is a nonprofit advocacy organization that conducts research and campaigns on consumer and public interest issues.

The details

Technicians must connect laptops or tablets to vehicles to locate failed sensors, release electronic parking brakes, or run diagnostics, and shops must pay manufacturer subscription charges and fees to obtain the required software tools. PIRG says independent shops may be forced to steer customers to authorized dealerships for about one in five jobs.

Timeline

  1. Auto insurance prices have risen three times as fast as the rest of the US economy since 2012.

  2. PIRG published the Closing Shop report on November 22, 2026.

Market Dynamics

The Closing Shop report documents how automakers' software subscription and access requirements have shaped a two-tiered repair market since 2012, when auto insurance prices began rising faster than the broader economy. The findings place repair access and insurance costs within a longer-running trend of rising consumer expenses tied to vehicle computerization.

Higher repair costs flow into insurance claims, which PIRG says raise the premiums drivers pay. Drivers who rely on independent repair shops may face longer waits or be steered to authorized dealerships for about one in five jobs.

The takeaway

Repair access is increasingly shaped by software rights as well as mechanical skill, so drivers comparing repair quotes may find that the choice of shop affects both cost and turnaround time. Checking whether a shop can perform software-dependent repairs before scheduling work can help avoid delays.

Further reading

Explore related coverage in the Insurance section for more on how repair costs affect premiums.

Source note: This article includes information reported by TheRegister.

Live Poll

Do you think your car repair costs have gotten higher over the past few years?