ACLU Urges Judge to Reject DOJ Bid to Hide Boat Strike Memo
The civil liberties group says the Justice Department's arguments for withholding a legal memo on military boat strikes should not succeed.
Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Law

The American Civil Liberties Union filed a nine-page memorandum of law asking a federal judge to deny the government's motion for summary judgment in a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit. The Department of Defense withheld in full a Justice Department Office of Legal Counsel memo on the boat strikes, citing FOIA exemptions and the presidential communications privilege.
Why it matters
The case tests how far the executive branch can shield the legal reasoning behind military action that has resulted in 234 deaths in the Caribbean since August 2025. The outcome could determine how much of the government's legal analysis of the strikes becomes available to the public.
The ACLU's filing asks the court to deny the government's summary judgment motion, and the Department of Defense has withheld the OLC memo in full under cited FOIA exemptions. Judge Engelmayer has yet to rule on whether any portion of the memo can be released after in-camera review, and his late October ruling on downstream dissemination remains a central reference point.
The players
American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)
A nonprofit organization founded in 1920 that litigates to defend civil liberties and constitutional rights in the United States.
U.S. Department of Defense
The federal department responsible for the armed forces, which conducted the boat strikes and withheld the OLC memo under FOIA exemptions.
U.S. Department of Justice
The federal department that houses the Office of Legal Counsel, whose memo on the boat strikes is at the center of the FOIA dispute.
Paul Engelmayer
A federal judge on the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York who is weighing the government's withholding of the memo.
The details
The Department of Defense carried out boat strikes under a presidential directive authorizing military force against foreign criminal groups, and it has said the targeted boats were trafficking drugs. Several Justice Department attorneys reviewed the memo as defense counsel in litigation over an October 2025 strike that killed two Trinidadian men, and the memo was also presented to numerous members of Congress.
Timeline
August 2025: The Department of Defense began attacking boats under the presidential directive.
October 2025: A boat strike killed two Trinidadian men.
December 2025: Litigation began after the ACLU's FOIA request.
Late October: Judge Paul Engelmayer issued a ruling addressing the scope of the presidential communications privilege.
November 21: The ACLU filed its nine-page memorandum of law.
Legal Context
The dispute turns on whether the presidential communications privilege and FOIA exemptions can shield an Office of Legal Counsel opinion from public release when that opinion underpins ongoing military operations. The case is a test of how courts apply longstanding disclosure law to executive branch national security legal analysis.
The outcome affects what the public can learn about the legal basis for military strikes carried out in the Caribbean. If the government's withholding is upheld, residents will have limited access to the reasoning behind operations that have killed 234 people.
The takeaway
Public access to government legal opinions is often decided in courtrooms, so following pending FOIA rulings is a practical way to track how much of the government's reasoning on military action becomes visible.
What happens next
Judge Paul Engelmayer's ruling on the government's summary judgment motion and on the ACLU's request for disclosure is pending, and no date for that decision has been set.
Further reading
For more background on the legal fights over government transparency, explore the Law section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Law & Crime.






