Groups Say Home Insurers Collected $113B Excess
Three advocacy groups report insurers gained $113 billion in excess underwriting income from 2021 through 2025 as premiums rose faster than claims.
Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Insurance

Live Poll
Do you think your home insurance premiums are getting better or worse?
Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, the Revolving Door Project and Public Citizen released a report on November 19, 2026, estimating that home insurers collected $113 billion in excess underwriting income from 2021 through 2025. The groups say homeowner premiums rose 59% over that period while claims payouts rose 28%.
Why it matters
The report puts a dollar figure on the gap between premiums and claims that homeowners have felt through rising bills, and it names profits, overhead and shareholder dividends as drivers. The $113 billion figure is the groups' own estimate rather than an independently verified finding, so the size of any excess remains open to dispute.
Premiums collected rose 59% from 2021 to 2025 while claims payouts rose 28%, and insurers paid roughly 55 cents in claims per premium dollar in 2025 compared with 69 cents in 2021. The groups' $113 billion excess estimate is measured against an 80% claims-to-premium standard they selected, and insurer responses to that benchmark were not included in the material provided.
The players
Liberty Mutual
Liberty Mutual is a large multinational insurance company headquartered in Boston, Massachusetts, that sells property and casualty coverage including homeowner policies.
Public Citizen
Public Citizen is a nonprofit consumer advocacy organization founded in 1971 that campaigns on issues including corporate accountability and consumer protection.
Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund
Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund is a nonprofit coalition that advocates for stronger financial regulation and consumer protections in the United States.
Revolving Door Project
The Revolving Door Project is a progressive watchdog organization that tracks the movement of officials between government and industry and the influence of corporate interests on policy.
The details
The report says insurers closed about 30% of claims without any payment between 2021 and 2025, and more than 22% of paid claims took longer than 60 days to settle. In Texas, premiums collected rose 78% over the same period while claims payouts fell 23%, and the largest Liberty Mutual home insurer in Texas raised rates by a cumulative 144%. The groups examined five states in detail: Texas, Iowa, Idaho, Maine and Florida.
Timeline
2021: Start of the period analyzed, with premiums at about $113.9 billion and claims at $78.4 billion.
November 19, 2026: Three advocacy groups issue the report.
2025: End of the period analyzed, with premiums at $181.2 billion and claims at about $100 billion.
Market Landscape
The report measures today's home insurance economics against a 1990s average loss ratio of about 74%, when insurers paid out a considerably larger share of premiums in claims. Against that benchmark, the roughly 55 cents paid per premium dollar in 2025 illustrates how far the claims-to-premium balance has shifted over the intervening decades.
Homeowners facing higher renewal premiums may want to compare quotes across insurers and ask how claims settlement timelines are handled before committing to a policy. The report's findings describe national and state-level trends and do not establish how any individual household's premium will change.
The takeaway
Rising premiums and slower claims payouts both affect what homeowners pay and receive, so comparing coverage terms and claims practices can help households manage costs. Readers can weigh the advocacy groups' estimates alongside regulatory data and insurer responses as they become available.
Further reading
Explore more on Insurance to see how premium and claims trends are shaping household coverage costs.
Source note: This article includes information reported by NJTODAY.
Live Poll
Do you think your home insurance premiums are getting better or worse?






