Kelly Thompson Questions Self-Funded Creator-Owned Comics

The DC and Marvel writer says her independent Substack-launched titles earned little return despite critical recognition.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Comic Books

Gouache-painted editorial illustration of a tall stack of blank comic pages with empty panel grids beside a single warm desk lamp, evoking quiet creative labor.
Writer Kelly Thompson said her self-funded, Substack-launched creator-owned comics, Black Cloak and The Cull, earned Eisner nominations but recouped far less than their investment. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would you pay more for creator-owned comics to help independent artists succeed?

Writer Kelly Thompson said she is frustrated by the financial realities of self-funded creator-owned comics. Her Black Cloak and The Cull, launched on Substack before Image Comics collected them, earned Eisner nominations but recouped far less than was invested.

Why it matters

The comments highlight a tension facing comic creators who balance lucrative work-for-hire contracts with independent projects. Creator-owned work can carry critical prestige while remaining less profitable than corporate assignments.

Black Cloak ran eleven issues and The Cull ran five, both self-funded and launched on Substack before Image Comics collected them. Thompson did not disclose exact figures for the amounts invested or recouped, leaving the scale of the shortfall unquantified.

The players

Kelly Thompson

Kelly Thompson is a comic book writer known for DC Comics' Absolute Wonder Woman and Marvel's Jeff, The Land Shark, and her creator-owned work has earned Eisner nominations.

Image Comics

Image Comics is an independent comic book publisher founded in 1992 by a group of artists, known for publishing creator-owned titles.

The details

Speaking on David Harper's podcast Off-Panel on SKTCHD, Thompson said Substack funding did not cover the cost of producing her creator-owned titles. She also said she does not attend comic cons or public signing events.

Timeline

  1. Black Cloak and The Cull launched on Substack, with a later collection by Image Comics (date not stated)

  2. Thompson's remarks were reported in an article published November 19, 2026

Roadmap

Creators increasingly launch independent comics on platforms like Substack before a publisher such as Image Comics collects them into print. Thompson's experience shows that critical recognition in this model does not guarantee the financial returns that work-for-hire assignments provide.

Readers who follow creator-owned comics may find fewer new independent series if creators cannot sustain their own funding. Fans can still support these projects by buying collected editions published by Image Comics.

The takeaway

Supporting creator-owned comics through collected editions and direct purchases helps sustain the independent work that publishers and platforms depend on. Readers can check collections from Image Comics for titles like Black Cloak and The Cull.

Further reading

For more on the independent publishing scene, explore our Comic Books coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CBR.

Live Poll

Would you pay more for creator-owned comics to help independent artists succeed?