NIH Asks Journal to Probe Fauci-Linked Paper

The National Institutes of Health wants Nature Medicine to examine whether Anthony Fauci, Francis Collins, and Jeremy Farrar made undisclosed contributions to a 2020 origins paper.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Life Sciences

NIH Asks Journal to Probe Fauci-Linked Paper

Live Poll

Do you trust scientists and government officials to be open about how research is shaped?

The National Institutes of Health asked Nature Medicine to investigate allegations that Anthony Fauci, Francis Collins, and Jeremy Farrar made significant contributions to the March 2020 paper "The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2" without that involvement being properly disclosed. The NIH letter asks the journal to consider whether the paper should be corrected or retracted.

Why it matters

The paper argued that available evidence did not support the virus being deliberately engineered or manipulated in a laboratory, so questions about authorship and disclosure bear on how the origins debate is documented in the scientific literature. NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya has called for a formal investigation into the matter.

The inquiry rests on an NIH letter to Nature Medicine and an October 1 HHS advisory opinion on authorship and attribution, which together frame the question of undisclosed contributions among five named authors. What remains unresolved is whether the journal will act on the request and how the disclosure allegations will be assessed.

The players

National Institutes of Health (NIH)

The NIH is the principal U.S. federal agency for biomedical and health research, and it sent the letter requesting the journal's investigation.

Jay Bhattacharya

Bhattacharya is the NIH Director who called for a formal investigation into whether the paper should be corrected or retracted.

Anthony Fauci

Fauci is the former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases who led U.S. pandemic-response science during the COVID-19 crisis.

Francis Collins

Collins is a former NIH director who led the agency through much of the early COVID-19 period.

Nature Medicine

Nature Medicine is a peer-reviewed biomedical journal published by Springer Nature that received the NIH's request.

The details

According to the NIH letter, obtained by German outlet WELT, Farrar convened a February 1, 2020 call involving Fauci, Collins, and several authors, and Fauci and Collins received and discussed early drafts. Farrar helped coordinate drafting and circulation and made at least one direct edit to the manuscript, while Fauci later referenced the paper during an April 2020 White House briefing.

Timeline

  1. March 2020: The Proximal Origin paper was published.

  2. February 1, 2020: Farrar convened the call involving Fauci, Collins, and the authors.

  3. April 2020: Fauci referenced the paper at a White House briefing.

  4. October 1: HHS issued an advisory opinion on authorship and attribution.

The Big Picture

The request revisits the Proximal Origin paper, which concluded in March 2020 that the evidence did not support deliberate laboratory engineering of the virus. How the journal and HHS resolve the disclosure questions will shape how that paper is treated in the record of the origins debate.

The outcome could affect how COVID-19 origins research is cited and corrected in the scientific literature that readers and researchers rely on. Any correction or retraction would change the publicly available record of a paper that shaped early pandemic-era discussion.

The takeaway

Authorship and disclosure standards matter for trust in scientific publications, especially on contested topics. Readers should watch for whether journal correction processes proceed transparently.

Further reading

Explore more coverage in Life Sciences.

Live Poll

Do you trust scientists and government officials to be open about how research is shaped?