Justice Department Defends PCLOB Firings in Court
Government lawyers argue a Supreme Court ruling supports removing two privacy board members from the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should presidents be able to fire members of independent federal oversight boards?
A Justice Department lawyer told the D.C. Circuit that the Supreme Court's Trump v. Slaughter decision supports President Trump's removal of Travis LeBlanc and Edward Felten from the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board. Senior Judge Reggie Walton had ruled the removals unlawful last year, and the administration appealed.
Why it matters
The case tests whether the president can remove members of an independent federal oversight board that reviews counterterrorism and surveillance programs. The outcome could determine how much control the White House holds over the board's five-member structure across the country.
The Justice Department argued the board is structured like other agencies without removal protections, while LeBlanc's attorney says Congress deleted the statutory 'serve at the pleasure of the president' language in 2007. The D.C. Circuit agreed to expedite its ruling.
The players
Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board
An independent federal agency that reviews counterterrorism and surveillance programs for privacy and civil liberties concerns.
Donald Trump
The 47th President of the United States, who fired the board members and whose removal power is at issue in the litigation.
The details
The board's Chair Sharon Bradford Franklin was also fired in January 2025, along with LeBlanc and Felten. The D.C. Circuit paused the case last year to await the Supreme Court's Slaughter decision before hearing arguments.
Timeline
2007: Congress revised the board's authorizing statute.
January 2025: LeBlanc, Felten, and Franklin were fired.
May 29, 2025: Justice Department argued before the D.C. Circuit.
January 2027: Beth Williams's board term is set to expire.
Legal Context
The D.C. Circuit's ruling will apply the Supreme Court's Trump v. Slaughter decision, which held that President Trump could fire FTC Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter. How that precedent reaches an oversight board with a rewritten statute will shape future presidential control over similar agencies.
The ruling will determine whether the five-member board that reviews surveillance programs remains independent or falls under direct presidential control. Its decisions affect how government privacy protections are applied to federal agencies nationwide.
The takeaway
Watch for the D.C. Circuit's expedited ruling, since it will set how far the Slaughter decision reaches into independent federal boards. The result will affect oversight of government surveillance programs.
Further reading
Follow related court coverage in the Law section for more on presidential removal power.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Vitallaw.
Live Poll
Should presidents be able to fire members of independent federal oversight boards?






