Lown Finds Hospitals Fall Short on Community Benefits

Just over half of nonprofit hospitals spent less on community benefits than their tax exemptions were worth, according to a Lown Institute analysis.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Philanthropy

Isometric editorial illustration of two unequal stacks of bronze coins side by side on a plain cream field, one visibly taller than the other.
Just over half of the nation's nonprofit hospitals spent less on community benefits in 2023 than their tax exemptions were worth, according to a Lown Institute analysis of IRS filings. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should nonprofit hospitals be required to give more back to their communities?

The Lown Institute analyzed IRS filings from more than 3,000 hospitals and found that just over half of nonprofit hospitals' community benefit spending fell short of their tax exemptions. Hospitals spent about $37.1 billion on community benefits in 2023, against $38.8 billion in industry-wide tax exemptions.

Why it matters

Nonprofit hospitals receive tax breaks in exchange for community benefit, and the findings raise questions about whether those exemptions deliver value to the public. The analysis also points to pressure on hospital finances from upcoming H.R. 1 policy changes.

Hospitals had $38.8 billion in industry-wide tax exemptions in 2023, averaging $12.8 million each, while the combined deficit of deficit hospitals reached $15.5 billion against a $13.8 billion surplus among surplus hospitals. Mayo Clinic Hospital posted the largest fair share deficit at $366 million, though the analysis does not explain every factor behind individual hospital results.

The players

Lown Institute

The Lown Institute is a nonprofit think tank focused on healthcare access and affordability that produced the analysis of hospital tax filings.

Mayo Clinic Hospital

Mayo Clinic Hospital is a major hospital that posted the largest fair share deficit in the analysis at $366 million.

Stanford Hospital

Stanford Hospital is an academic medical center in California that posted a $255 million fair share deficit in the analysis.

New York-Presbyterian Hospital

New York-Presbyterian Hospital is a large New York academic medical center that posted a $248 million fair share deficit in the analysis.

Massachusetts General Hospital

Massachusetts General Hospital is a Boston teaching hospital affiliated with Harvard Medical School that posted a $219 million fair share deficit in the analysis.

The details

Lown calculated each hospital's fair share by comparing tax exemptions with community benefit spending drawn from IRS forms matched to Medicare cost reports. Its tax exemption measure includes federal and state corporate income taxes, sales taxes, property taxes, tax-exempt bonds, tax-exempt donations, and federal unemployment tax exemptions.

Timeline

  1. 2023: Most recent year of IRS Form 990 data analyzed

  2. November 17, 2026: Lown released the analysis on Tuesday

Philanthropy Context

The findings test the community benefit standard that underpins federal tax exemptions for nonprofit hospitals, asking whether tens of billions in forgone taxes return proportionate charitable value. Lown's call to amend nonprofit hospital exemptions and set spending targets would reshape that long-standing bargain.

Patients at nonprofit hospitals may see changes in charity care and community programs if the tax exemption rules are amended as Lown has proposed. Shifts in hospital finances tied to federal policy could also affect the services available in communities that rely on these institutions.

The takeaway

Nonprofit hospital tax breaks are a public trade-off, and readers can check how their local hospitals report community benefit spending on their IRS Form 990 filings. Asking hospitals about charity care policies is a practical way to see whether that trade-off is being met.

Further reading

For more on how charitable giving and nonprofit accountability work, explore our Philanthropy coverage.

Live Poll

Should nonprofit hospitals be required to give more back to their communities?