AMA Finds Insurer Dominance in Nearly Half of Metros
An American Medical Association analysis of 2025 data finds one insurer holds at least half the commercial market in 47% of metro areas.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Healthcare

Live Poll
Do you trust your local health insurers to treat patients fairly?
The American Medical Association released an analysis of 2025 data from 385 metro areas across all 50 states and the District of Columbia. It found that at least one health insurer held 50% or more of the commercial market in 47% of those metro areas.
Why it matters
Under federal merger guidelines issued in December 2023, 95% of metro area commercial markets were classified as highly concentrated in 2025. Concentration levels in the commercial market matched those seen in 2014, and the analysis points to limited competition among insurers across much of the country.
UnitedHealth Group held the largest national commercial market share at 15%, while Blue Cross Blue Shield plans combined held 42%. Commercial market concentration reached a 10-year high in Connecticut, Illinois, Indiana, Montana, South Dakota and West Virginia.
The players
UnitedHealth Group
A diversified health care company and the largest U.S. health insurer by national commercial market share in this analysis, with operations in insurance and health services.
American Medical Association
The largest association of physicians and medical students in the United States, which released this analysis of insurer market concentration.
Blue Cross Blue Shield
A national federation of independent health insurance companies whose member plans combined held 42% of the commercial market in this analysis.
CVS Health's Aetna
The health insurance business of CVS Health, one of the largest managed care operators in the United States.
Elevance Health
A large managed health care company that operates Blue Cross Blue Shield plans in several states.
The details
The analysis identified the two largest insurers in each metro market and measured concentration against thresholds set by federal merger guidelines. At least one insurer held a commercial market share of 30% or more in 90% of metro areas, and at least one held a Medicare Advantage share of 30% or more in 88% of metro areas.
Timeline
2014: Commercial metro concentration reached the same level measured in 2025.
December 2023: Federal merger guidelines were issued, setting the thresholds used in the analysis.
2017: 99% of Medicare Advantage metro markets were highly concentrated, the high point before the 2025 figure.
2025: Market data examined in the analysis.
November 17, 2026: The AMA released the analysis.
Market Landscape
The analysis measures insurer concentration against the thresholds in the federal merger guidelines issued in December 2023. Measured against those thresholds, commercial concentration in 2025 matched the 2014 level, while Medicare Advantage concentration eased slightly from its 2017 peak.
Patients in markets dominated by a single insurer may face fewer plan choices and less negotiating leverage over premiums and provider networks. Employers buying coverage in highly concentrated markets may have limited alternatives when renewing group plans.
The takeaway
Insurer concentration is a structural feature of many local health markets, so checking which insurers are available in your metro area can help you understand your coverage options. Comparing plans each enrollment period shows whether a dominant carrier is limiting your choices.
Further reading
For more on how market structure shapes the sector, see Healthcare coverage on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Becker's Hospital Review | Healthcare News & Analysis.
Live Poll
Do you trust your local health insurers to treat patients fairly?










