Grimes Worried About Marshals Without Kelsey Asbille

The Yellowstone actor says he questioned reprising Kayce Dutton in the spinoff after the loss of Monica Dutton.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Rodeo

Flat-color Western frontier poster illustration of a weathered fence line and a lone hat against an open plain and distant ridge.
Luke Grimes said he struggled to picture Kayce Dutton in the Yellowstone spinoff Marshals without Kelsey Asbille's Monica Dutton, whose character has died. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Luke Grimes admitted he was worried about reprising Kayce Dutton in Marshals, the Yellowstone spinoff, without Kelsey Asbille, who played Monica Dutton throughout Yellowstone. Grimes told Screen Rant he could not wrap his head around Kayce without Monica, since the story was about the two of them.

Why it matters

The concern centers on how a spinoff can carry a character whose emotional core was tied to a departed co-lead. Marshals is now in its second season, and the show is exploring Kayce's growing bond with U.S. Marshal Andrea Cruz while he still wears his wedding ring.

Marshals is in its second season, airing Sundays on CBS and streaming on Paramount+, with Ash Santos playing U.S. Marshal Andrea Cruz. The source reports no ratings or viewership figures for the season.

The players

Luke Grimes

Luke Grimes is the actor who plays Kayce Dutton across the Yellowstone franchise and is reprising the role in Marshals.

Spencer Hudnut

Spencer Hudnut is the executive producer and showrunner of Marshals, a role he holds on the Yellowstone spinoff.

Kelsey Asbille

Kelsey Asbille is the actress who played Monica Dutton throughout Yellowstone and is not part of the Marshals series.

The details

Grimes spoke to Screen Rant about his concerns regarding the spinoff and said he discussed the timing of removing Kayce's wedding ring with executive producer and showrunner Spencer Hudnut. Kelsey Asbille played Monica Dutton throughout Yellowstone, and Monica has died.

Timeline

  1. Before agreeing to the series, Grimes was worried about doing Marshals without Asbille.

  2. In the show's second season, Marshals explores Kayce's bond with Andrea Cruz.

Season Trajectory

Marshals extends the Yellowstone franchise into a second season, carrying Kayce Dutton's storyline forward after the events that closed the parent series. The spinoff's direction depends on whether its new relationship with Andrea Cruz can stand on its own without Monica.

Viewers who follow Marshals can watch the second season on CBS on Sundays or stream it on Paramount+. Fans tracking Kayce's storyline will see whether the show keeps his wedding ring and his grief over Monica in view as his bond with Andrea Cruz develops.

The takeaway

Spinoffs built around a grieving character often succeed or fail on how openly they keep that loss in the story. Marshals' handling of Kayce's ring and his new relationship will show whether the show treats Monica's absence as a continuing thread.

Further reading

For more on the franchise's western roots, explore our Rodeo coverage.