Law Professor Outlines How Trump Could Challenge Midterms

Seattle University's Erin Carr describes legal tools a president could use after Trump questioned midterm results online.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Elections

Law Professor Outlines How Trump Could Challenge Midterms

Live Poll

Do you think the president should accept the midterm election results?

Seattle University law professor Erin Carr outlined ways President Donald Trump could challenge midterm election results. Trump has posted online claims questioning results and raised issues with voting machines, despite promising weeks before the election to accept the outcome.

Why it matters

The newly elected Congress takes office in January, and Democrats won control of the incoming House in the midterms, so disputes over results could shape how power transfers and how oversight of the executive branch proceeds across the country. Carr said Trump's rhetoric follows a pattern of election denialism and unsubstantiated voter fraud claims.

Trump's posts over the past two weeks questioned polling versus outcomes and raised voting machine concerns, following a pre-election pledge to accept results. Whether any formal challenge follows, and how congressional Republicans would respond, has not been determined.

The players

Donald Trump

Donald Trump is the current President of the United States, a Republican who has repeatedly questioned election integrity claims.

Erin Carr

Erin Carr is an assistant professor at the Seattle University School of Law who specializes in constitutional law, civil rights and legal history.

The details

Carr, an assistant professor at the Seattle University School of Law who specializes in constitutional law, civil rights and legal history, spoke on Good Day Seattle on Monday morning. She explained that the president has legal authority to direct the Department of Justice or other federal agencies to open investigations, and that as head of the Republican Party he could pressure GOP leaders to use procedural maneuvers to delay or refuse seating newly elected Democratic members.

Timeline

  1. Weeks before the election: Trump promised to accept the outcomes.

  2. Past two weeks: Trump posted online claims questioning midterm results.

  3. Monday, November 16, 2026: Carr discussed possible challenges on Good Day Seattle.

  4. January 2027: The newly elected Congress is set to take office.

Political Context

Carr frames Trump's midterm claims as part of a pattern of election denialism that echoes disputes over the 2020 presidential results. Incoming congressional leaders are expected to take their oversight roles very seriously and reinvigorate scrutiny of the executive branch in ways not seen during Trump's first two years of his second term.

Disputes over midterm results could affect whether newly elected members are seated in January and how federal oversight proceeds. Voters should watch official certification and seating decisions, which determine which lawmakers hold office.

The takeaway

Election legitimacy depends on institutions following through on pre-election commitments to accept outcomes, and the seating of Congress in January will be the practical test. Readers should track official certification records rather than social media claims.

What happens next

The newly elected Congress takes office in January 2027, when any seating disputes over Democratic members would have to be resolved.

Further reading

Explore more on Elections coverage across the country.

Source note: This article includes information reported by FOX13 News | Seattle & Western Washington | Formerly Q13 News.

Live Poll

Do you think the president should accept the midterm election results?